Tuesday, June 13, 2006

Getting Jobbed at Wal-Mart

In today's NY Sun the paper reports that Wal-Mart is opening up a new store in Kearny, NJ, and the company received more than 8,000 applications for work. The Wal-Mart take, seconded by all of its commentator toadies, is that this deluge of applications means that "we are bringing good jobs with good benefits, and tremendous career opportunities into this community."

Well, not so fast fellas. We've been through a lot of this before, and it's useful to reiterate the fact that there are costs as well as benefits in the Wal-Mart equation-something that all of the acolytes fail to mention. What no one on that side of the ledger points out is that over the past decade 13,000 supermarkets have closed in Wal-Mart's wake. In this scenario the Walmonster's jobs have replaced those where workers were receiving much better compensation packages.

This is the process that the NY Times calls Walmartization-the replacement of locally owned businesses and unionized workers with less well-compensated retail employment. If Wal-Mart came into Monsey or NYC would there be lines of folks ready to accept the new jobs? Of course there would be, but that doesn't dilute the argument that the costs don't outweigh the benefits. Would the lines be any shorter if Wal-Mart actually paid their people better and provided for their health care?

Wal-Mart's Scope-A-Dope in Monsey

We've just received a copy of a draft scoping document, required under NYS SEQR rules, that has been prepared for the Planning Board of the Town of Ramapo. What we see in front of us is a seriously deficient document that fails to address a number of key issues. It is now incumbent on the Board to reject this scope as inadequate.

The major deficiency, and we're still examining the document along with Brian Ketcham our consultant, is its failure to consider the economic impact of the giant retailer on the areas existing neighborhood stores. In the more rigorous NYC CEQR rules the examination of both "direct" and "indirect" displacement of business is required.

As far as Wal-Mart is concerned we have a well-documented record of the store's devastating impact on existing stores in a community. Given these well-recorded dangers it is imperative that the Ramapo Planners demand that the developer of this store include an analysis of the Walmonster's impact on business in its EIS.

In addition, it is also imperative that the EIS include a full Wal-Mart market study as part of its impact analysis, This study would enable the Town to better understand just where Wal-Mart's customers are going to come from. Once this is known, it is possible to more fully understand potential traffic patterns. Without this data all of the consultant's traffic figures are basically unrefutable since no one would be able to judge the accuracy of the estimates without a benchmark.

So, given these deficiencies we're calling on the Planning Board to send the Wal-Mart consultant back to the planning board. Otherwise the Alliance and its allies may have no choice but to legally challenge the certification of the Draft EIS. There's simply no way for a document that is deficient from the start to somehow address key issues that it never felt were necessary to address in the first place.

Monday, June 12, 2006

Community Gored #4

Patrick Arden continued his good reporting on the shenanigans in the Bronx last week when he detailed the actions of BBP Carrion in respect to the recomposition of Community Board #4. This reaction by Adolfo, the decision not to re-appoint certain members because of their opposition to the Yankee Stadium deal, and the demotion of a number of committee chairs, sheds a great deal of light on one of the worst kept city secrets: local community boards, especially in the Bronx, represent the powers that be and if they go off the reservation thinking differently, well, you get what happened last week.

The story is picked up today in the NY Post and it talks about the BP playing "hardball" with his foes on the board. The Post also discusses, in a separate story, some of the hurdles that the theft of city parkland for the new stadium will face in Washington.

All of which raises questions about the legitimacy of the community input during the city's ULURP process and adds another reason to the compelling need to reform the entire procedure. Now don't get us wrong, you're never going to get a "politics-free" process, it's just that some better mechanism for community review is needed. And thanks to BP Carrion the rationale is crystal clear.

Saturday, June 10, 2006

Palisades Mall Traffic: A Wal-Mart Lesson

There's a front page story in today's Rockland Journal News about the continuing efforts to mitigate the traffic going into and out of the gigantic Palisades Mall in West Nyack. What's instructive for us is the fact that the Clarkstown Planning Board, which approved the original traffic design in the early nineties, failed to envision any of the current problems even though critics were quick to point them out at the time.

All of which should be an object lesson for the Ramapo Planning Board as it looks to review plans for the Wal-Mart supercenter on Rt. 59. Planners need to weigh carefully the contentions of all of the paid experts who are brought in to tell them that the increased traffic volume can be easily mitigated.

What usually happens is that the subsequent mess, all because of store demand that couldn't have possibly been anticipated by the experts, is left to the town and county to fix-usually at the tune of hundreds of millions of tax payer dollars. In addition, the added "social costs" of accidents, fatalities and lost work time is never even figured into the equation.

It is now the job of the Alliance and its allies in Monsey and the rest of Ramapo to make sure that the surrounding communities are on high alert for the usual developer snow job when it comes to the evaluation of the traffic impacts that a project of this size will generate. The old adage of-"Figure don't lie, but liars figure"-needs to be applied to the Walmonster's expert witnesses.

Friday, June 09, 2006

Park Your Trash Here

The NY Times is reporting today that Speaker Quinn is backing a key element of the mayor's solid waste plan and may be getting close to a deal with Bloomberg on his proposed SWMP. The key agreement is on using part of the Hudson River Park site down near the Gansevoort Market for a recycling center. As the Speaker told the Times, "...that Manhattan should be responsible for disposing of its own waste, and that a recycling center could be operated at Gansevoort Street without disrupting the park..."

Still up in the air is the fate of the proposed commercial transfer station that the mayor has slated for 59th Street and the proposed residential one at 91st Street on the East Side that has caused so much controversy. The tentative agreement on Gansevoort has already sparked sharp disagreement from parks advocates and Quinn's erstwhile colleagues in the state legislature who represent the area. As Assemblymember Glick told the Times, "It's not the most helpful thing, but it is certainly not the last word."

Indeed it is not. In the middle of all of this is the proposal, Intro 133, to actually try to do something to reduce the city's commercial waste so that a waste station does not need to be built at 59th Street. As we have been saying all along there is nothing in the mayor's plan that does this. Without realistic waste reduction strategies the city's SWMP is doomed to be a bottomless money pit (cha ching Waste Management) and a real threat to New York's businesses that are inevitably going to be stuck with an enormous garbage bill.

Wal-Mart All Coked Up

The Alliance has worked on behalf of neighborhood food and beverage retailers for the past twenty five years. One of our first campaigns was waged on behalf of independent beer and soda distributors and it was designed to prevent the big guys-particularly Coke and Budweiser-from monopolizing the distribution system.

One of the things we learned early was how powerful Coca Cola was. In 1980 they had used their clout to get Jimmy Carter to push through a franchise territory law that preserved their hallowed three tier distribution network. Anyone who tried to "transship" Coke was going to have a major legal headache.

With Coke you had two choices: buy their product from the local route man or don't sell the stuff at all. How times have changed and guess who we have to thank? You guessed it-Wal-Mart. As CNN reported yesterday, "Coke caves under Wal-Mart pressure."

It seems that the beverage giant was being pushed to directly deliver its Powerade brand to the Wal-Mart warehouses instead of through the traditional store-door method. And, facing a freeze-out from the retailer, Coke caved and went direct prompting a lawsuit from 55 of its smaller bottlers (the same folks the franchise bill was designed to protect). In essence Wal-Mart, in effect, forced Coke to eat its own young.

Coke panicked because it was afraid that Wal-Mart would develop its own competing sports drink brand and Powerade would become toast. Talk about power! This is what the small retail and wholesale businesses of America are up against. If you can make Coke buckle, then everyone is at risk.

Thursday, June 08, 2006

More Monsey Traffic Mayhem and Wal-Mart

The concern about traffic along the Rt. 59 corridor, a concern that we have highlighted as a big problem for planners considering the merits of the proposed Wal-Mart in Monsey, is once again spotlighted in today's Journal News. This time it is the intersection at Rt. 306 and the concerns are very real. In 2004 there were 23 accidents resulting in six injuries at Maple Avenue with one injury at Rt.306 and Rt.59.

In order to address the seriousness of this traffic threat the Town of Ramapo is planning to go forward with a $1.2 million "traffic safety project" that looks to reduce pedestrian accidents that are particularly present in this "walking community." As Ramapo Supervisor Christopher Lawrence told the Journal News, "We have a lot of kids in the area. Mothers are pushing kids in baby carriages and they fight with traffic on Rt.59."

The problem is that there are no real sidewalks in the area and pedestrians are forced to walk on the street. "That, Ramapo Detective Sgt. John Lynch said, can be a deadly combination." A 67 year old Monsey women was killed by a cement truck as she tried to cross 59 last year.

As everyone quoted in the story pointed out, "The traffic is a nightmare." And now just when you think things couldn't get worse, along comes Wal-Mart to add to the 21,000 cars that travel through the 59-306 intersection.

All of which adds to everything that we have been warning Monsey about. As our traffic consultant Brian Ketcham tells us time and time again there are "social costs" to the project that never get considered. Among these costs is the inevitable increase in the number of pedestrian accidents, and yes fatalities, that will occur when you add thousands of new vehicle trips every day. These are costs that are borne, not by Wal-Mart, but by the good citizens of Monsey.

The Ramapo Planning Board is scheduled to certify the Wal-Mart traffic study and EIS next Tuesday. Our sources are telling us that the Board is going to allow the developer to do the minimal "scope of work." If so, this will be a great disservice to all of the communities that are going to bear the brunt of the Wal-Mart impact. It might also very well result in a lawsuit against the town.

This can all be avoided if Supervisor Lawrence breaks his inexplicable silence on the issue and instructs his planners to insist that this project undergo the strictest review. As the paper points out, ..."with a Wal-Mart Supercenter...both pedestrian and vehicular traffic are likely to increase."

The current proposals are like trying to bandaid a shotgun wound. As one small businessman said, commenting on the already nightmarish conditions on the corridor, "I have no idea how they can solve this problem...I don't know what they can do. This is a walking community. There is a large Jewish population. Friday night to Saturday night; they only walk."

Taxing Issues

The flap over Denny Farrell's tax "philosophy" is a good start to the upcoming gubernatorial debate. While we have great admiration for Eliot Spitzer and his potential to shake Albany up in a good way, we also feel that John Faso's anti-tax platform will help focus attention on the overburdened tax payers in this state.

Denny, who has a history of being anti-business, particularly small stores, needs to sit quietly in the corner and allow this debate to go forward. His continued pontification on policy issues is only going to shed unwanted light on a particular big government mindset that is too prevalent in the NYS Assembly. Spitzer needs to keep a good distance from all this.

Wednesday, June 07, 2006

Racial Flap Continues in the Yards

AS Metro reported yesterday and Ben Smith continues today in the NY Daily News, the racial backbiting over comments made by DDD's Daniel Goldstein continues. All of this is unfortunate because it obscures the debate over the merits of the development and pollutes any reasonable discussion.

What's clear to us is that there is a damned if you do, damned if you don't, quality about the criticism that the FCRC is "buying" the black community's support. For a very long time developers in this city have plowed ahead with a "community be damned" attitude that ignored any direct attempt to provide positive support for the impacted neighborhoods.

So now Forest City directly engages the local community, promulgates a CBA-the first of its kind in NYC-and includes an affordable housing component whose percentage far exceeds the norm, and for all of its pathbreaking efforts gets demonized by opponents.The irony here is that FCRC is also being demonized by many other prominent developers in the city precisely beacuse of how it has directly partnered with the local community.

Put the AY situation into context and compare it with what went on in the Bronx with the BTM. As Metro reported yesterday Patrick Canale, a long time member of Community Board #4, is leaving the board with a bad taste in his mouth. Canale was asked to participate in the "negotiation" over a CBA for the Gateway Mall.

The so-called CBA was in reality a "Carrion Benefits Agreement." As Canale says, "He formed all the committees...We found out that it was the borough president's deal. We were just wasting time again. We were negotiating among ourselves, and he negotiated with Related himself. When it came time to the finished agreement, nobody wanted to sign."

There will always be disputes about who does or doesn't really represent the community. In Brooklyn, with Daughtry, Sharpton, Lewis, Coach Screen, Renan Ebeid from Lincoln High and Jocko Jackson from Brownsville all on the side of the Yards the grass roots support is both wide and deep. To paraphrase Justice Stewart's comment on pornography, "We may not be able to define what the community is, but we know it is when we see it."

Tuesday, June 06, 2006

Baldor's, EDC and RFP Fairness

As we have already commented the city's actions over the Baldor's RFP raises some good questions about how the EDC makes its land use decisions. The article in today's NY Daily News points out some additional issues that should be examined by the City Council. It appears to us that, given Judge Billings' observations, the legislature should be looking to have more oversight before the ULURP process commences.

What the judge observed in this case was an apparent pattern of both favoritism by EDC and dissembling by Brian Murphy, Baldor's CEO. The reason for all of this sleight-of-hand was that the city was trying to find a way out of the BTM by using the abandoned Baldor's site as a destination for the BTM merchants.

As the News points out, "Baldor was also aware that the city wanted to secure its current site in order to relocate ethnic food merchants from the Bronx Terminal Market..." All of which is quite strange to us since the city never thought it wise to actively involve the merchants themselves in all of this maneuvering.

In any case, All Hail Judge Billings! Unlike the lamentable Judge Cahn, who saw precedents were none should have been found in the BTM litigation and toadied up to EDC in the process, Billings examined a rotten process and ruled accordingly.

All of which could set some interesting precedents of its own. As winning attorney Mastro told the News, the judge's decision "'speaks volumes about how shocking and unfair the city's disposition process was here'...and could set a 'very important precedent' involving future city requests for proposals.'"

Heads up Willets Point!

Dropping the Baldor

According to Crain's the city is going to have to re-open its bidding process for a 15 acre site that EDC had all but earmarked for Baldor's Specialty Foods. In her ruling Judge Lucy Billings had found that the bid process had been "skewed" and proceeded to annul the agreement.

What Billings also found was that the city had "failed to disclose a central criterion on which [it] intended to base its lease award..." In addition the judge agreed with the Hunts Point Produce Cooperative that the city had steered the site to Baldors because of its desire to help the city with its BTM relocation effort. Here's the judge's money quote:

"Although respondents denied communications about this objective, contradictions in the evidence, both related and unrelated to this precise issue, make those denials incredible"

The Astroturf Plantation

Just when you thought that it couldn't get any worse for the DDD group that has been fighting the AY development, it did. The group's trusty leader, Daniel Goldstein, accused the various supporters of the development ("plundering astroturf groups") of fronting for their "white masters."

There are a number of legitimate reasons for neighborhood groups in and around the development to oppose the project. There are also some good reasons for the groups that support the project to feel that, on balance, AY is a good thing for Brooklyn and the city. We've also stated our support the project and have done so by acknowledging the paid role of Richard Lipsky.

The Alliance has spent the better part of three decades opposing much of the mega-development in this city. We have done so generally on behalf of small businesses and the communities they're located in. When RL was approached on the AY development there was a great deal of analysis and some degree of soul searching before the decision to support was made.

Part of what made the decision easier was the variety, quantity, and quality of the groups and individuals that signed on to support the project. Given these supporters it is quite sad to see Mr. Goldstein resort to the language of slavery to demonize the likes of Bertha Lewis, Al Sharpton and Herbert Daughtry. The fact that he is holding a losing hand doesn't excuse the intemperate remarks.

Monday, June 05, 2006

Transportation Planning in Rockland?

Yesterday's Rockland Journal News gives a preview of a meeting of the New York Metropolitan Transportation Council that will be held on Tuesday at the Palisades Mall. The purpose of the Council's "listening sessions" is to gather ideas from citizens about transportation issues that concern them the most.

Since one of the crucial issues that faces traffic planners is the proliferation of box stores and shopping malls it is indeed ironic to convene anything that deals with traffic over at the biggest mall in the Hudson Valley. On second thought maybe it is the most appropriate venue to examine the traffic problems facing Rockland; the eye of the storm as it were.

As we have been commenting in this regard one of the biggest challenges facing the county is the fact that each town and village reviews development in its jurisdiction without any input from contiguous communities that are sure to be impacted by the projects approved by their neighbors. This is especially unfortunate when it comes to the problems manifested by any proposed Wal-Mart.

So we plan to be at Tuesday's forum and the issue we will present is, how does a region devise traffic plans amidst the autonomy of towns and villages? We will also raise the problem of box stores such as Wal-Mart and the challenge they pose to sustainable development.

Friday, June 02, 2006

Monsey Wal-Mart Townhall Meeting

It's just about set; a townhall meeting to discuss the implications of building a Wal-Mart super center on Rt.59 in Monsey. The meeting is tentatively set for Spring Valley High School, a short step down from the site, on Tuesday, June, 27, 2006.

The focus of the gathering is to galvanize the diverse impacted communities about the various dangers posed by the development. The meeting will be sponsored by the Alliance, the Ramapo Jewish Chamber of Commerce and the UFCW. It will focus primarily on three key issues: traffic, crime and small business.

Joining us on that evening will be the Alliance's traffic consultant, the inimitable Brian Ketcham, and the good folks at WakeUp Wal-Mart who have been studying the issue of crime generation at the Walmonster. In addition, Abe Stauber of the RJCC will discuss the implications that the store has for the hundreds of locally owned businesses. We also expect that we will be joined by quite a few of the areas local elected officials since we believe that the Wal-Mart issue will be central to the upcoming electoral fight to replace the disgraced Ryan Karben.

Thursday, June 01, 2006

Wal-Mart Watch in the Bronx

When the City Council approved the Gateway Mall project earlier this year, an approval that made a special arrangement to accomodate BJ's, concern was raised that the Bronx might be fertile ground for a booty capitalist thrust for Wal-Mart. Hence, the conference scheduled for Friday by WakeUpWal-Mart.

The purpose of the conference is to galvanize all of the community, labor and small business stakeholders in the borough in order to head the Walmonster off at the pass. From the looks of things the response has been overwhelming and attendance will be strong over at Hostos College.

As we have been commenting the key to Wal-Mart's entry into NYC is the ability of the retailer to garner Black and Latino support through the cooptation of minority developers and small business groups. The company has already started in this direction by collaborating with the ultimate booty capitalist-Frank Garcia and his Bronx Hispanic Chamber of Commerce. It has also joined the mainstream Bronx Chamber as well.

The Wal-Mart tactics are being noticed nationally. In the April edition of Inc Magazine the Alliance's Matt Lipsky was quoted commenting on the effort by Wal-Mart to elicit small business support; "They know their biggest criticism is their negative impact on small business and they're trying to cover that up."

In the current issue of the magazine there is more comment on the giant retailers tactics. In an article titled, "Wal-Mart: the little guy's champion?, James Schrager, a University of Chicago business school professor, tells Inc that the new Wal-Mart initiative is a "grab bag of silliness" but goes on to say that "They'll wipe out all of the inefficient ma and pas, which is a good thing."

Except for the mom and pops themselves, but give the prof props for a degree of honesty that the Wal-Mart folks-and their paid acolytes like Mr. Garcia-lack. It reminds us of all the Polish nationalists who welcomed the Nazi invaders only to become the first victims of Hitler's wrath.

That is why the presence of Alfredo Placeras at Friday's conference is so welcome. Placeras is a true voice of Hispanic business and he, along with Jose Fernandez of the Bodega Association, Sung Soo Kim of the Small Business Congress and Paul Fernandez of the National Supermarket Association, is a legitimate representative of small, minority business.

Wednesday, May 31, 2006

Bronx Terminal Market: RIP

As Metro reports, today is the last day of operation for the Bronx Terminal Market whose wholesalers are being replaced by the Gateway Mall. This turn of events is the culmination of a spirited though unsuccessful battle on behalf of the BTM and it saddens us that many of these establishments, after being split up and offered inadequate compensation, may go out of business.

Reporter Patrick Arden talks to a couple of the merchants who are doing their best to relocate but are uncertain about whether they can survive apart from the other vendors. Complicating matters is that in the Bronx especially, space is quite limited:

“We didn’t find enough space in the Bronx,” said Ricardo Duarte, who started Cuba Tropical 28 years ago with his son, Omar. “Now we’ll have 30,000 square feet — and no parking.” He laughed ruefully, and then his eyes misted over. He’s had to move part of his operation to New Jersey.
Stanley Mayer, the head of the merchants association, has found space nearby and we hope his optimistic prediction turn out to be true:

“It’s not over yet,” he added. “You won’t know until some time goes by to see if it’s going to work. A year from now, we’ll all know. If everybody’s still in business, I guess we’re OK.”

ED in the Yards

We have been commenting extensively about the complexities of the entire eminent domain question. Much of the debate over last summer's SC Kelo decision centered around the court's expansive definition of what constitutes a "public use."

Those who disagreed with Kelo generally felt that public use should be more narrowly construed to mean things like schools, roads or bridges. In general, the higher court left this decision in the hands of local political authorities and many critics felt this created a dangerous situation because local politics is often dominated by real estate interests.

Our position has always been less absolutist than that of the severest critics of Kelo. Our position has been that great care needs to be exercised when property is taken and the greatest degree of transparency must be present when development entails the use of ED.

Which brings us to the Atlantic Yards controversy. Does the exercise of the eminent domain option so that FCRC can take other peoples' property to build an arena and 7,000 units of housing constitute public use?

In today's NY Times the paper reports that opponents of the plan have suffered another legal setback in their efforts to derail the project. Undaunted one of the unsuccessful lawyers tells the Times that "We believe in the moral correctness of our case, and are confident that this decision will inspire the public's vigilance and scrutiny to grow even stronger..." Where does morality really lie here, if it lies here at all?

While it is quite true that the Alliance's Richard Lipsky is retained by FCRC to help build support for the project in the sports communities of Brooklyn it is also true that the debate over public use needs to be evaluated on its own merits. Does providing affordable housing for thousands of Brooklyn residents constitute as much a public use as any road?

Will putting thousands of New Yorkers to work be a defendable public benefit? How about creating a not-for-profit alliance to promote youth sports in the borough? One can see just how nuanced this whole public use clause can become.

In fact in this month's libertarian Reason magazine Justice Alex Kozinski, considered to be somewhat of a libertarian himself, underscores this very point when he tells his interviewer, "So if the city thinks there should be a private business instead of a private house, it has to make that decision. If you want to decide on your own, you can go live in a forest."

Kozinski goes on to point out that even the so-called public roads are built for the convenience of millions of private vehicles: "What matters is that it makes it easier for other people to get from point A to point B using their private vehicles for private purposes.You could say 'but its my house and my private purpose is more important than your private purpose.' But we live in a society."

So it all comes down to politics. We elect our mayors and our councilpersons and we need to hold them accountable. If we're unable to do so-whether at the BTM or AY-than we need to do a better job of organizing and educating. And if FCRC does the kind of grass roots outreach that galvanizes large swaths of Brooklynites, well, that's poltics in the big city. The Alliance has suffered some devastating defeats and we try to never let today's defeat spoil tomorrow's victory. Be better organized, do better media outreach, get a stronger coalition in place. Most of all, learn from your mistakes so you don't repeat them.

Tuesday, May 30, 2006

Support for Atlantic Yards

In today's NY Daily News, Errol Louis takes a shot against a group of Brooklyn celebrity notables who've added their names to a "Develop-Don't Destroy" advisory board. DDD is the leading opponent of the Atlantic Yards project. Heath Ledger's wife Michelle Williams is singled out by Errol for her lament that "Heath and I moved to Brooklyn for light and space and air."

There are a number of legitimate reasons to oppose the development, foremost among them is the use of eminent domain to oust long time homeowners. There are, however, even more compelling reasons to support the project, a development that will create 7,000 units of housing and thousands of part time and full time jobs.

From the Alliance's perspective the most salient reason to join hands with FCRC, Build and Acorn is the bringing of the Nets to Brooklyn with a brand new arena. When the Alliance's Richard Lipsky was an up and comer plying his basketball wares all over the city, Brooklyn was a mecca for all BBall pilgrims. It still is, and the love for the game is beyond what even we would have imagined when we first began to evaluate the AY proposal.

The Brooklyn Nets are going to galvanize the entire borough and the team and its ownership is going to play a major role in working along with the youth leaders of Brooklyn in their tireless and unacknowledged efforts on behalf of the kids. That is why the support has been so unequivocal from these community folks.

All over Brooklyn the support has come in for the newly created Brooklyn Sports Alliance. Leaders such as Carlton Screen from the Flatbush Youth Association, Joe Murphy from the Brooklyn Saints, Rich Kosik from Books-N-Ball, Jocko Jackson from the Brownsville Recreation Center, Jim Dolan from the Police Athletic League and Reginald Murray from the Brooklyn Rams-just to name a few- have already donated their time and energies to helping get the BSA started.

They know a good thing for the young people of Brooklyn because many of them have devoted their time and efforts to the kids for the better part of three decades. They are being joined by the coaches of Brooklyn. Already the BSA has had over forty coaches and athletic directors pledge their support and cooperation. People such as Coach Rock Eisenberg of Tilden, AD Renan Ebeid of Lincoln, Coach Saunders of Banneker, Coach Seltzberg of Grady, Coach Nash of Bishop Ford and Coach Shavon Glover, one of the leaders of girls basketball in the PSAL, have rolled up their sleeves to work with and advise the BSA on how best to help the youth athletic efforts in Brooklyn.

As we have said, the BSA is not just about generating support for AY. It is about forging a long term relationship between the Nets and the kids of Brooklyn with the goal of using sports to promote, in Rich Kosik's phrase, a "game plan for life." Sports can be a positive influence on the development of healthy and decent young people. This is especially true when the activities are guided by strong, morally upright community leaders. In the end their can be no better example of sustainable development than this.

Moynihan Station

In yesterday's NY Times editorial the paper more or less kvells over the design for the new Moynihan Station. For those of you who aren't Yiddish speakers this means that they really like the plans to create a new modern train station on Eighth Avenue.

They do, however, make one interesting observation on the development that bears repeating. They point out that the original proposal, "a grand public plan with a minor private component" has been transformed into "an enormous private development with a significant public component."

What this means is that the two developers, our favorite real estate companies-Related and Vornado-will be getting an "extraordinary boon" (along with previous persona non grata at City Hall, James Dolan of MSG). Isn't it quite interesting how these two firms seem to have a monopoly on merit when it comes to Deputy Dan Doctoroff and ESDC?

Which brings us to the competition over the Willets Point development. We've already observed that Vornado has pulled out, but isn't it possible that they've removed themselves temporarily only to resurface later as partners with the folks at Related? When does the clamor for integrity in government extend to the fiefdom of EDC?

Congestion on RT. 59: Wal-Mart Watch

As we have been commenting, the proposal to build a 216,000 sq. ft. Wal-Mart in Monsey is going to complicate the severe traffic conditions that already exist on the Rt. 59 corridor. What has also concerned us is the ad hoc manner in which planning is done in Rockland County. Since all projects are the responsibility of each town and village it becomes impossible to plan comprehensively for the region.

This complicated planning mess is illustrated by a story in Sunday's Rockland Journal News. It seems that the town of Airmont, right on the Ramapo border and just a short run up from the site of the proposed Wal-Mart, is poised to approve another strip mall on the corner of 59 and Airmont Road. According to the paper, citing county and state figures, "Nearly 30,000 vehicles approach the intersection daily on North Airmont Road, and 18,200 travel between the corner and downtown Suffern..."

All of which demonstrates just how problematic it is to plan. In essence each separate jurisdiction looks at a project in a vacuum without any real consideration for its impact on surrounding communities. In addition, most environmental reviews are narrowly focused, never deviating away from a relatively narrow radius around a proposed development.

The final scoping session for the Wal-Mart in Monsey is on June 13th. Early indications are that the Ramapo officials are aware of some of our concerns and those raised by Brian Ketcham, the Alliance's traffic consultant. In the weeks and months ahead we will be reaching out to the local communities to make them fully aware of the myriad problems created by a Walmonster.

Friday, May 26, 2006

Bid Adieu?

The Crain's Insider is reporting this morning that State Supreme Court Justice Lucy Billings, the judge who threw out the award of a 15 acre site in Hunts Point to Baldor's Foods, "may order sweeping changes in the way EDC operates..." The result could very well lead to a ruling that would "specify how EDC is to handle future bids."

For all of us who have marveled at the nimble nature of the EDC bidding process this prospect promotes nothing but anticipatory glee. Anything that creates a degree of transparency and fairness in the awarding of land use contracts is only to the good.

Not that we think any ruling will be earth shattering. These processes tend to revert to form through altered channels once a new direction is mandated. What would be really revolutionary would be the creation of a COIB that actually acted in an independent manner. In fact maybe the City Council, instead of firing pop guns at lobbyists, could look into the Deputy Dan/Steve Ross decision of the COIB as a first step towards making the agency truly independent.

Vornado Doesn't Get the Point

In yesterday's NY Sun Dave Lombino reports that mega real estate developer Vornado has withdrawn from the Willets Point competition. The reasons aren't quite clear since the realtor refrained from commenting on the story, but according to sources "high costs for land acquisition and environmental remediation make it a difficult project to build and finance."

These aren't the only reasons, however. A major source of consternation is the fact that EDC is trying to get all of the applicants to submit proposals and after they do the agency is planning to take One good idea from Column A and One from Column B and so on. After cherry picking all of the best concepts EDC plans to award the development to one firm with all of the other companies' good ideas served up on a silver platter for the winning bidder.

From a development standpoint there is one giant hurdle-EDC's desire to rezone the property prior to the selection of a developer. We just can't see the City Council accepting this kind of sight unseen maneuver. The only way that the council can have an impact is if a designated developer with a plan comes before it for an approval. Rezoning without these in place appears to us to be a non-starter.

L.I. Indians on Warpath

In yesterday's Newsday the paper is reporting on the effort by two Long Island Indian tribes to form a coalition to protect "a vital source of our economic activity..." The activity in question just happens to be the illegal avoidance of paying taxes on the sale of cigarettes sold to non-Indians.

The representatives of the two tribes in question argue that an "overwhelming majority" of New Yorkers "supprt our ability to become self sufficient..." We wonder what New Yorkers would say if they knew that this whole scam was costing tax payers in the state hundreds of millions of dollars a year in lost revenue.

Thursday, May 25, 2006

Trouble in the Night

The latest furor over a bad apple bouncer at a New York City night club has predictably triggered the call for new legislation. As the NY Sun reports this morning Speaker Quinn and Council Public Safety Chair Peter Vallone Jr. are proposing a law that would "use the city's Nuisance Abatement Law to punish bars that hire criminal bouncers-a role that the State Liquor Authority has had from its inception."

Without being too flippant we've often found that it is the new law that is often more of a nuisance than the malady it seeks to address. And by the way, even though we've never been great friends of the tort lawyers we do think that the civil liability penalties for clubs that hire drug addicts or homicidal maniacs is a strong enough deterrent, along with a more vigilant police enforcement policy.

The complaints about the Authority amount to little more than a non sequitur when it comes to the issue of a trigger happy bouncer. To rag on the SLA only misconstrues its function in the course of a feel good breast beating about the evils of indiscriminate shooting of innocent clubbers. Our friend Rob Bookman gets it right: "I think there are enough laws on the books to deal with the bad apples."

Lobbying and Its Discontents

We're often put in the unenviable position of having to defend the work that we do. Lobbying, and the saga of Jack Abromoff is the latest example, is not an activity that people rate right up there with heart surgery or fire fighting. We do, however, think that lobbying has gotten a bad rap.

Part of this bad rap comes from the fact that most people tend to want to view politics in some kind of idealized, Hallmark card way. In this view elected officials should be folks imbued with the public good whose only concern is the overall welfare of the citizenry. Inevitably this view founders on the reality of politics and when it does, cynicism disillusion and discontent follows.

The reality of politics is the often messy tussle of various so-called special interests, something we have commented on before. It is not only messy it is also no place for the faint hearted. When public policy is at stake there are winners and losers. The allocation of scarce resources provokes a great deal of vicious in-fighting among competing interests.

What is often missing in the public commentary about this process is the observation that almost all of the competing interests have some degree of merit. For every policy winner who gets legislation passed or a contract let there is some amount of public benefit that accrues. The developer who wins an RFP gets to build a project that provides jobs and homes and amenities that benefit a larger public constituency.

Quite often the special interest is a union that represents the interests of thousands of workers. What's "special" to some observers is a public interest to others. The genius of the democratic system is the way in which it allows all of these interests to interplay in the over all policy dance that ends up with what we believe is the best approximation of what the public good stands for.

Which brings us to yesterday's City Council lobbying reform, legislation that Richard Lipsky describes in today's Newsday as "a bill {that} overestimates the impact that lobbying has..." Perhaps a better word in this context would be "mischaracterizes" rather than overestimates.

It goes back to the heart of our original observation that people tend to want to see the political process as "pure" and when it proves to be something different we get the kind of moral impulse that is inherent in the lobbying package passed yesterday. As Lipsky points out the impulse behind lobbying reform tends to ignore the fact that "lobbyists often push issues that genuinely lead to better public policy for New Yorkers..." Our final point here is that Machiavelli got a bad rap as well.

Wednesday, May 24, 2006

Wal-Mart Affront

In today's Crain's Insider the newsletter reports on the effort that Wal-Mart has launched to coopt the "booty capitalists" that we have been telling one and all about. The title of the Crain's post is "Wal-Mart Front?"

The front in question is the New York State Hispanic Chambers of Commerce and this group is being called out by the established NYS Federation of Hispanic Chambers, a group that actually represents real Hispanic businesses and has existed for decades. As Crain's points out, mirroring our own take on the booty kissing, the Walmonster is looking to replicate its success in Chicago where it used minority contractors to make its first store opening an issue of minority empowerment.

Ominously, Crain's says that Wal-Mart has joined six chambers in the city in its quest to cultivate (purchase?) legitimacy. We expect that there will be an expanded outreach by the company as it continues to scout out locations for stores.

A Wal-Mart Eminent Domain Twist

A small town in California aptly named Hercules is threatening to use eminent domain in order to acquire property Wal-Mart wants to build on. The City Council has already twice defeated the proposal and the general sentiment is anti-Wal-Mart but this hasn’t stopped the world's largest retailer from continuously trying to subvert the town’s wishes. Explaining why they are considering such a drastic measure, a Hercules resident remarks:

"We want something good to take that place," said Jeffra Cook, a Hercules resident since 1988. "There aren't a lot of good stories about Wal-Mart."
Citing destruction of small business and increased traffic, residents of this 24,000 person town don’t want to see their small town way of life destroyed by Wal-Mart. While threatening the use of eminent domain is definitely extreme, it’s a reasonable reaction to a company that doesn’t understand no. As a Wal-Mart Watch spokesman points out, considering Wal-Mart’s history, the Hercules’ decision to protect itself in this manner isn’t that drastic:

But Wal-Mart has been at least as successful at imposing its will on communities that are less than thrilled to host one of its stores, said Nu Wexler, a spokesman for the activist group Wal-Mart Watch.

In one instance, the company even raised the specter of eminent domain to get a store built in Florida, he said.

"Wal-Mart does not hesitate to employ scorched earth tactics to break into communities that don't welcome them," he said.

Wal-Mart tops local police calls

Via Wake Up Wal-Mart, a local sheriff in Washington State finds that Wal-Mart generates the highest number of calls to his police force. According to an article in the Columbian:

Wal-Mart isn't just the number-one retailer in the universe. It also leads
the way in calls for help to local police.

No west-county property generates more calls-for-service to the Clark County Sheriff's Office than Wal-Mart on Northeast Highway 99, according to a sheriff's report.
Local residents are already concerned about a new Wal-Mart recently approved in the area; these crime statistics are only going to increase their concerns. The sheriff report also tabulates the number of man hours devoted to law enforcement at Wal-Mart and the results are astounding:

After factoring in the multiple officers, multiple vehicles, paperwork and transportation to-jail time required for felonies and other serious calls, the sheriff's office estimates devoting 936 hours last year to law enforcement at the Hazel Dell Wal-Mart.
Wow!

Tuesday, May 23, 2006

Durst, Disposers and the DEP

The battle over the city's SWMP has been narrowly focused on the issue of the siting of new marine transfer stations. The thornier issue of waste reduction has been less salient, understandably so from the mayor's standpoint since there is little in the draft plan that offers much in this key area.

As we have been arguing all along, the use of food waste disposers is the only realistic methodology that can reduce waste in the most economical and environmentally effective manner. As it turns out the Alliance has a new ally in this waste reduction fight, an unlikely one given our usual set cohort of belligerents. The ally is the Durst Organization.

Durst is concerned about the siting of a commercial transfer station on the river at 59th Street in Manhattan. Aside from the fact that it has expensive property rights in the area the organization makes a number of good points about the inappropriateness of the site and the existence of a better location near the rail yards a mile south.

Of course what is most heartening to us is the support the company gives to the expanded use, in both the residential and commercial sectors, of food waste disposers. This support, given in City Council testimony and a more comprehensive report that accompanies it, lays out a number of important arguments that mirror the Alliance's position on disposers and waste reduction.

What gives the report heightened credibility is the fact that it was drafted by former sanitation commissioner Brendan Sexton who brings to the task an expertise and understanding of the issues from the perspective of an insider. Brendan not only has been in the middle of the garbage disposal issue he is also someone with a sensitivity to the tendency of city agencies to obfuscate on controversial policy matters.

His take on the disposer issue is instructive and can't be dismissed lightly. In the first place he argues that the expanded use of residential disposers, particularly in Manhattan, can save the city hundreds of millions of dollars a ear in disposal costs (18.5% of the city's garbage is now food waste). Importantly, he underscores the public health benefits of disposer use and the impracticality of composting in a hi-rise apartment environment.

Sexton also points out, and given the hysteria from some quarters you'd be shocked to discover this, that FWDs "are ubiquitous and many large cities-including Los Angeles, Philadelphia, Detroit, Columbus (OH), and Denver, to name a few-mandate their use..." In fact Sexton is so confidence about the efficacy of their use that he advocates incentivizing their installation much like the city has done with low-flow toilets.

What About the Nitrogen?

The great bugaboo on the use of disposers is the danger that nitrogen effluent poses for some of our surrounding waterways. Now Professor Robert Ham has debunked some of the alarmism on this issue but Sexton also effectively addresses this issue. He cites the DEP's own report on the subject and demonstrates that the costs are greatly exaggerated by the agency.

In addition, he also points out that the costs cannot be analyzed without a simultaneous evaluation of the benefits of disposer use. As he says, "While additional costs may well be incurred by DEP in order to handle increased liquefied food waste, this must be properly weighed against the enormous costs the City and its tax payers will incur handling the same material as solid waste."

Most importantly, however, Sexton calls on the city to conduct a "rigorous, transparent and independent study," one that takes into consideration not only costs but also savings. This is precisely what we have suggested on the commercial side and it is integral to Intro 133.

Sexton underscores many of our arguments about the utility of commercial disposers but there is one point he makes that is central to our concerns about the public discussion of this issue and the lack of candor in some of the statements that have been issued by DEP.

The agency has said that it would cost billions to retrofit the waste water system to accomodate disposers. In a letter written by the former DEP commissioner it is stated that in order to handle the nitrogen loading from commercial disposers "an entirely different technology" would be required at an estimated cost of between $4 and $10 billion.

Sexton's take on this is instructive: "We find curious Mr. Ward's suggestion that somehow current goals can be met by retrofitting but that any substantial additional nitrogen loads would suddenly require a completely different technology costing billions; perhaps upon a serious and transparent review, the situation would not prove to be 'all or nothing' in the way that Mr. Ward suggests." Indeed!

Monday, May 22, 2006

More Hokey Pokey

The South Bronx is looking for a "Get Out of Jail Free Card." As we have been commenting, and as the NY Times reported on yesterday, the jail bait and switch maneuver by Deputy Dan and EDC has foisted a new corrections facility on a community that has had more of its share.

When the BTM/House of D sleight-of-hand was accomplished to make the world safe for Steve Ross and Related it was never publicly stated that the Bronx would be needing additional jail space to make up for the demolition of the old jail. After all, especially with a $400 million price tag for a new jail, wouldn't it have been more cost effective to rehab the existing facility?

In addition, doesn't this new reality raise more questions about the BTM-House of D swap? Shouldn't new questions be raised about simply swapping these properties {without any appraisals of their relative worth} so Related could build a mall? If the tax payers are now being stuck with a huge bill for a new jail that the surrounding neighbors of Oak Point don't want shouldn't some of this cost be borne by the Related freeloaders?

What's missing in the Times story is any comment from the council members who supported the original Gateway deal. There are copious comments from all of the community leaders but none from the council woman who not only represents the area but who was also one of the leaders in the House of D charade and the BTM demolition.

The last word on all of this goes to Majora Carter of Sustainable South Bronx. She complains about the infusion of public money for the Yankees and Gateway and say, "The city's response is, 'Oh, we're going to spend $400 million here, too, but we're going to use it to put you guys in prison'...They need to recognize the irony of that."

Wal-Mart Warning for Monsey

In new study done by Stephan Goetz of Penn State University on the correlation between Walmartization and poverty rates (posted on Wal-MartWatch) there is one observation that is particularly germane for the good people of Monsey, New York. It is the impact of the displacement of local businesses by the Walmonster.

Here is the money quote: "In conclusion, the costs to communities in terms of labor replacement and higher poverty need to be weighed against the benefits of lower prices and greater shopping convenience. Similarly, once local businesses have been driven out, the possibilities of monopolies or ologopolies emerging in retailing...needs to be considered carefully by public policymakers." (emphasis added)

This is a message we've been sending to the good people of Monsey, a community where there is a high level of entrepreneurship that is important to the maintainance and support of communal institutions. The cost of the displacement of these local retailers must be weighed very carefully.

Protecting the Public Markets and Doing the Hokey Pokey

The controversy surrounding the eviction of the BTM merchants and the approval of the Gateway Mall refuses to go away. We were chatting with Councilmember Palma the other day about the proposal to build a new $370 million jail in Hunts Point and it becomes clearer by the minute that the transfer of the House of Detention to Related was a massive fraud.

According to Palma there is no way that the Bronx delegation would have approved the Gateway deal if it had known about the jail bait and switch. It was, according to her, bad enough that the House of D was basically given away without any bid competition. To now find out that the city is going to spend hundreds of millions of dollars more to replace the correction facility only adds more fuel to the scandalous fire.

Which brings us back to the original issue that was litigated: The right of the city to ignore basic provisions of the Charter that deal with the disposition of city property because of the imagined "market exception." Not so imagined, however, because of the inane ruling by a formerly respected jurist named Cahn.

If the judge's ruling is allowed to stand than the businesses and workers in the public markets face a greater risk than the one posed by Rudy Guiliani's putative attempt to rid these markets of the influence of organized crime. Put simply, Cahn's legal ruling is so expansive in its interpretation of the so-called power of the Commissioner of Small Business Services that it would seem to obviate the need for Local Law 28, the legislation that put the markets under a vast network of city oversight in 1997.

Clearly Guiliani and his deputy Randy Mastro didn't think so. After all, no one ever accused the former mayor of reticence when it came to an expansive interpretation of mayoral authority. If he felt it necessary to codify his new market regulations than you can be confident that this so-called market exception is a chimera, a sheer fantasy of Jesse James Masyr, Related and Deputy Dan.

What needs to be done? A coalition of the vulnerable needs to be set up to address the travesty of the Cahn job. Locals 342 and 202 need to join with the Hunts Point meat and produce companies and their cohort in the other public markets.

Legislation needs to be introduced at the City Council that exposes the fallacy of this illegal power grab and clarifies the limits of the mayor's power when it comes to the public markets. If this is not done than we can expect that the mayor will find other opportunities to act arbitrarily and capriciously when it comes to regulating the businesses and thousands of workers in the city's public wholesale markets.

As far as the jail bait controversy is concerned, it provides the Council with yet another opportunity to investigate the actions and improper conflicts of the city's deputy mayor for economic development. Everyone gets righteously upset when an elected official puts his hand down the pants of an intern. We need the same level of righteous anger when economic development officials screw hard working small businesses because of personal relationships with developers.

Friday, May 19, 2006

Wal-Mart Watch: Close the "Below Grade" Loophole

We have already discussed the ingenuity of Jesse James Masyr when it comes to exploiting loopholes in the NYC zoning laws. The major loophole we have highlighted is the one that allows a developer to avoid the need to obtain a "special permit" for a food or department store larger than 10,000 feet in an industrial zone by building the store a certain number of feet below the street level.

This is an exception that makes absolutely no sense since there is nothing about below grade that should allow for the obviation of an environmental review. Yet it exists and it is used. The Pathmark on Waters Place in the Bronx and the Stop-and-Shop on Grand Avenue in Maspeth are two of the most salient examples of the loophole in action.

Now we are hearing that Masyr and Related are thinking of using it to build a BJ's warehouse store that the City Council gave a thumbs down to in February of last year. Even more ominous, if the loophole is not closed we can expect that some crafty developer will use it to bring in Wal-Mart and avoid any ULURP death knell.

Karbenated

When we first heard the news that Rockland assemblyman Ryan Karben had resigned we anticipated the worst. Of all the electeds we know Ryan is perhaps the least likely (with one major exception who will remain nameless) to just suddenly resign. No, there had to be be a firing squad poised to execute and, as it turns out, there undoubtedly was.

All of which got us thinking about the late great Harold Lasswell whose book, Psychopathology and Politics, explains the process by which "private emotions are displaced onto public objects." Clearly politics attracts a number of otherwise disfunctional personality types who are attracted to the public adulation.

Still it is quite sad to see a capable and talented young man go down in flames, destroyed by the very demons that probably pushed him into the political arena in the first place. Here's hoping that he can reconstruct his life and get the kind of help that will enable him to sort out his own needs in a more low-key arena.

Thursday, May 18, 2006

Garbage Costs Spiral

The NY Times is reporting today on the sanitation budget hearing that was held yesterday before Mike McMahon's City Council committee. Commissioner Doherty testified and it now appears that the cost of closing the Fresh Kills landfill is now going to exceed $1.4 billion. Just another example of how these original cost estimates need to be taken with a grain of salt.

In this regard it is important to highlight that none of the city's estimates when it comes to the construction of waste transfer stations and the resulting garbage exports can be taken at face value. The city's SWMP will inevitably be a fiscal black hole and the primary reasons are the dependence on an export-landfill methodology and the failure to devise a credible waste reduction plan.

What mystifies us, however, is the uncritical support for the plan coming from the local environmental lobby. The Times points out that, "Environmentalists support the plan because it emphasizes recycling and seeks to haul more garbage by barge and rail than by truck..." This is a complete fantasy, at least in regards to the recycling issue.

How many times do we need to point out that the "Emperor's New Clothes" has nothing on the mayor's recycling proposals. Put simply, there is no concrete proposal to increase the city's recycling efforts. All we have gotten is the typical jawboning that amounts to little more than feel good BS.

Which is why the Alliance's advocacy of food waste disposers makes so much sense on so many different levels. Whether we're talking about waste reduction, increased recycling, reduced truck traffic or improved public health, the use of FWDs can play a critical role. That is why we're confident that Intro 133 will be moved in the coming short term. It just makes sense to try this approach on an experimental level and, hopefully, expand it into a key waste disposal methodology.

Where, Oh Where, Has My Wal-Mart Gone?

This week's Crain's New York Business has a piece ("Wal-Mart's Long Search"$) on the difficulties that Wal-Mart is encountering trying to find an adequate space for a store in New York City. As the company says, "We're interested in New York, and we're looking at all possible options."

The article doesn't really break any new ground and reiterates an observation that we've made in the past that the best site would be an as-of-right location that didn't have to go through land use review. This is easier said than done. In addition, it is likely that the first store would only sell dry goods and not groceries because, unlike the Crain's take, such a move would allow them to avoid, or at least minimize, the UFCW's opposition while settling for a smaller, easier to locate, building at the same time.

Clearly, however, developers are scared of getting the Wal-Mart version of tar baby. As Jesse James Masyr points out Wal-Mart "adds a level of political hysteria to the project..." In response to its critics the Walmonster is trying to woo minority groups and small businesses. But, as Crain's points out and we agree, "Still, the overtures may not be enough to help the company find a suitable site in New York."

Willets Point Showdown

In yesterday's NY Times, old friend Terry Pristin focused on the controversial plans to redevelop Willets Point. As we have said in the past we believe that this will be a major battleground over the use of eminent domain. The city's position is that the Point is the ideal area to use ED. Deputy Dan told the Times, "In some ways, this is the most compelling case for eminent domain...It has nothing to do with uses. It has to do with intolerable conditions."

Clearly, however, the local businesses disagree and have hired Peter Vallone to defend their interests. Just how the former speaker is going to do this remains a mystery to us. Peter is the consummate deal maker and is no street fighter. In addition, his perceived closeness to the mayor doesn't seem to be the kind of weapon that would be suitable to the stand and fight crowd.

Nevertheless the city has issued its RFP and has given eight firms the right to respond. Most of the heavy hitters are involved and the city sees the area as ripe for a hotel and convention center as well as major retailers. Housing is considered optional but area officials like Councilman Monseratte are going to insist on an affordable housing component.

The real controversy will revolve over what to do about the existing businesses. As the recently release Hunter College report done by Professor Tom Angotti underscores, "these businesses form a cluster that would be hard to duplicate elsewhere." Where have we heard this argument before? The BTM merchants made the same case but it fell on deaf ears.

What's different at the Point is the sheer volume of existing business and the aggressive leadership of Monseratte. The city and EDC would be wise to consult here and not try to dictate. Knowing the councilman as well as we do we're sure that he is going to insist on a balance of equities. This is particularly true since the Angotti study estimates that roughly 80% of the work force is Hispanic.

Willets Point should provide for the proper opportunity to debate the issue of ED and the resolution of the controversy should be done in the context of crafting a more nuanced ED policy. What this means is that a balance needs to be reached, one that acknowledges and preserves much of the neighborhood economy while looking forward to developing new economic opportunities as well.

Wednesday, May 17, 2006

Caveat Vendor

Crain's Insider is reporting this morning that City Councilman Alan Gerson is going to propose recommendations "to rein in street vendors." The councilman calls the current situation "vendor anarchy" and we agree.

Gerson is likely to propose a task force to "simplify rule-making and enforcement which are split among at least four city agencies." The Alliance has been active on one aspect of this out-of-control situation but we welcome Gerson's attention to the overall problem. His comments this morning are on point: "The current rules are not being enforced, in part because some of them are not easy to enforce."

That being said, the fiasco with fruit vendors needs to be addressed with an immediate legislative remedy. We will be meeting with the speaker and council staff shortly and are hopeful that this will happen soon.

Mastro and the Merchants

In today's NY Daily News the paper reports that merchants at the Hunts Point market are planning to bid on the site that the city had, according to Judge Billings, improperly awarded to Baldor's Foods. Judge Billings plans to force EDC to issue a new RFP for the 15 acre city-owned site.

As we commented yesterday, the Alliance was skeptical that the city's "sham bidding process" had anything to do with a desire on their part to accommodate the BTM merchants. In a post we did last year we pointed out that the site had been deemed unsuitable by the merchants prior to the mayor's press conference announcing the Baldor's move.

We did, however, have a conversation with Randy Mastro, the attorney for the Hunts Point wholesalers. Randy is convinced that the city saw the Baldor's site as an alternative for the BTM merchants and a way out of the public relations nightmare that the Alliance had created for the city. Perhaps, but if so it only increases our disrespect for the way that EDC conducted the entire BTM business.

Mastro also was quite candid in his disdain for the judge's ruling on the BTM. He told us that it made no sense for the city to have the power, under the "market exception," to in effect eliminate the facility that the power applied to. In addition, he agreed with our assessment that, under the logic of Judge Cahn's ruling, Rudy Guiliani and Randy Mastro didn't need to get to the council to pass Local Law 28 (The public markets measure), because the inherent powers already existed.

All of which seems to point toward the need for the City Council to address the travesty of Judge Cahn's ruling. The ruling, if left standing, makes a mockery of the City Charter and puts all of the public market businesses and workers at risk.

Tuesday, May 16, 2006

BTM Merchants Win!

In what amounts to the ultimate irony a judge ruled yesterday that a bidding process that awarded a Hunts Point site to Baldor's Foods was invalid because the city had in essence rigged the bid in favor of Baldor's in order to solve its political snafu with the BTM merchants. So the merchants who fought long and hard, yet unsuccessfully, to remain in the BTM now get to be the source of at least one legal victory.

As the NY Sun reports this morning Randy Mastro, the lawyer for the Hunts Point Produce Cooperative, had argued that the whole bid process was a sham: "The city conducted a sham competition, when it had in mind all along that it wanted to steer the property to Baldor." Now we have no doubt that the process was rigged, just as the awarding of the BTM site was to Related, yet we seriously doubt that the reason for the collusion was the plight of the BTM merchants, as much as our agreement with the premise would credit the work that the Alliance did on the merchants behalf.

To agree would be to acknowledge that the city at any point gave a tinker's dam about the plight of the merchants. The reality is it never did and EDC was upfront about its lack of concern. We believe that the "offer" of the abandoned Baldor's site was strictly an afterthought since the city never had any prior discussions with the merchants prior to the Baldor's relocation announcement.

That is why the comment by merchant rep Stanley Mayer in the NY Times this morning is right on point. "Mr. Mayer said that almost all the merchants knew where they were going but none of them planned to move to the Baldor's building. 'It's beyond ironic,' he said."

Hats off, however, to Mastro and to Judge Lucy Adams Billings who saw the collusion and moved to put a stop to it. Maybe Judge Cahn should take a new look at his travesty of a legal ruling that ceded the BTM to Related. There's as much chance of that happening as finding Judge Crater.

Sunday, May 14, 2006

Rockland Planning Problems and Wal-Mart

As yesterday's Rockland Journal News points out the nature of county governance in Rockland makes proper planning extremely difficult. The reason is that a comprehensive plan runs up against New York State law that "gives towns and villages-and not counties-the authority over planning and zoning."

Yet Rockland legislative chair Harriet Cornell is moving forward with a county plan be cause she sees overdevelopment and concomitant traffic as key issues. Cornell believes that the new county effort and the work of the towns and villages is "complementary" and not "competitive." "She also said that more elected officials, and appointed town and village planning and zoning board members, were interested in better planning."

All of which is very nice sounding but altogether too theoretical. Case in point: Wal-Mart in Monsey. Here is a huge regional center that will impact all of the towns and villages in a ten mile area but only the town of Ramapo will get to review and act on the proposal. This certainly doesn't sit well with neighboring Spring Valley. And we're sure that Airmont and Suffern would welcome the opportunity to weigh in on the development, particularly on the manner in which the Walmonster will impact their communities.

What needs to be done is for the legislature itself to convene hearings on the environmental, economic and social impact of this huge retail project. It needs especially to use its own resources to evaluate the Wal-Mart proposal and, if necessary, develop some safeguards to prevent the development from wrecking local communities and small businesses. This is too big a deal for just one town to be given full authority to approve or disapprove.

Friday, May 12, 2006

Wal-Mart on Staten Island: A Bridge Too Far?

In an article in yesterday's Staten Island Advance Councilman Mike McMahon recounts being stuck for two hours on the Goethals Bridge. He said that he used this experience to come to a position of opposition to the NASCAR development. Our point has been that there needs to be a moratorium on large regional developments on the Island until major reconstruction of the road infrastructure is completed.

What this means is that the idea of putting a Wal-Mart in Totenville needs to be scotched until the road improvements move beyond just a wish-list phase. We're betting that all of the councilmembers on the Island will agree and the Walmonster will be forced to relocate once again.

Bureaucratic Expertise

The hearing yesterday at the City Council's Small Business Committee on two bills that would create a level of due process fairness went extremely well and we send special kudos to Chairmen David Yassky and the bills' sponsor, Councilman Jim Gennaro. Gennaro in particular since we have had our differences with him over the pilot program for garbage grinders. What Jim showed yesterday that he does have a strong concern for the city's shopkeepers.

The hearing did get a small amount of coverage in the NY Post today and the paper focused on the "loony laws" that the city has on the books (like the law that says you can't wash the sidewalk with a hose). We've always said that the city code is confusing, out-of-date and needs to be overhauled. That being said, we need to insure that all aspects of the regulatory process get reformed, since shopkeepers are being fleeced from enforcement on the street right on to adjudication at ECB.

Bloomberg's Rebuttal

As we expected Mayor Bloomberg, undeterred by the legislative turn down of the Governor's cig tax hike proposal, has quietly gotten state law makers to introduce his 50 cent a pack boost to the city's current cigarette levy. As the NY Post reports this morning the increase would raise the price of a pack to $7.50.

As per usual the city is citing the claimed health benefits of the tax hike and, in the process, ignoring evidence from all over the country that declining rates of smoking show no correlation to state tax rates. What is, however, beyond dispute is the effect that the increases have on area store owners. In 2002, the city increase led to a sales loss of over $250 million to local bodegas, newsstands and green grocers.

What is missing is any degree of recognition by the city that the tax has led to drastic business losses and the concomitant increase in cigarette smuggling. The city's enforcement effort has been woeful yet the DCA continues to vigorously monitor legitimate stores ignoring street sales.

Enough already. There should be no cigarette tax hikes until the city and state start to (a) enforce the law against Indian retailers and; (b) start to vigorously interdict the smugglers. IN addition, Bloomberg should immediately join with John Castimatidis in his lawsuit against Indian retailers.

Thursday, May 11, 2006

Small Business Going Bananas

The Crain’s Insider ($) reports today on our efforts to reign in and better regulate fruit and vegetable street vendors. We are in the process of drafting the legislation and will hopefully have a hearing shortly.

One of the reasons that the peddler issue is so nettlesome to legitimate store owners is that they also under constant attack from the Department of Consumer Affairs and the fine-collecting Environmental Control Board (ECB). We’ve already commented that the ECB is basically a kangaroo court where small businesses are assumed guilty, given the highest possible fines and therefore often don’t show up because they already know that protesting is useless.

As a response to this small business concern, 2 bills are being introduced – 64-a and 66-a – that clarify the ECB’s authority. There will be a press conference today at 9:30 where Councilman and Small Business Committee chair David Yassky, the Alliance and other small business groups will push for adoption of these measures. Though there are many other issues that need addressing, making sure that the ECB cannot use mom and pop businesses as their regulatory cash cows is an important step to improving the city’s business climate.

Wednesday, May 10, 2006

BJ's Dishes Dirt?

What's this we're hearing? It appears that our friends at BJ's, aided and abetted by the sly one himself, Mr. Jesse James Masyr, are contemplating making an end run around the city's zoning laws. The focus is once again Brush Avenue in the Bronx, where last year the City Council, in a unanimous vote at the Land Use Committee, the body turned down a zoning request to build a 150,000 sq. ft box store for the chain.

Since then a number of events have transpired. In the first place some Bronx council members have had second thought$ about the wisdom of bringing the non-union store to the borough. At the same time the election of Jimmy Vacca, an opponent of BJ's, to represent the area where the site is located has complicated the chain's desire to locate at the Brush Avenue site.

Enter the always scheming Mr. Masyr. Jesse is the master of the "below grade" ploy, the exploitation of a loophole in the city's zoning text that allows a builder to avoid the need for a special permit if the building in question is built at a certain number of feet below grade. He accomplished this for a supermarket in the Bronx as well as one for Queens.

Of course the loophole makes no sense since the environmental impacts of the project are not altered if the elevation of the building is lowered. Yet the loophole exists and now we have heard that BJ's has been investigating the removal of millions of pounds of dirt from the Brush Avenue site in order to avoid ULURP for the box store.

Now iot's one thing if you find a below grade area and can utilize this existing anomoly to avoid the zoning laws. It is, at least it appears to us, that it is quite a different order of things entirely when you excavate a site in order to become below grade. This is literally driving a bulldozer through the zoning loophole.

It does, however, throw down a challenge to Councilman Vacca and the leadership of the City Council. The Related Company is in constant need of good will from the council in its myriad development projects. The council leadership should not let this situation fester for a moment longer than is necessary.

It should be made chrystal clear to Jesse James Masyr and his Related cohorts that this ploy will not be tolerated. The Brush Avenue site was deemed inappropriate once before and no amount of dirt digging should be allowed to alter the facts already on the ground.

Tuesday, May 09, 2006

It Ain't Easy Being Green

It appears that Gristedes' John Castimatidis isn't the only one upset by the greenmarket proliferation. It now has come out that the greenmarket that was approved by Community Board #8 on the East Side has been torpedoed due to the opposition of retailer Eli Zabar.

As the NY Post reports this morning Eli Zabar's opposition to the proposed and approved greenmarket on the playground of PS 6 has led to its demise. In the Post's inimitable phraseology, the greenmarket "bought the farm."

The plug was pulled because the market sponsors were afraid that the site was going to be picketed and the sponsors didn't want "growers to be subjected to that sort of behavior." For his part Zabar, just like Castimatidis and Morty Sloan Nick D'Agostino and the folks at Food Emporium, didn't want the city streets used-free of charge-to compete with tax paying businesses.

Maybe now the City Council will begin to understand the importance of nurturing and not harming neighborhood retailers. In particular we will be looking to see if we can get the council to enact legislation that significantly restricts the activities of the legion of fruit and vegetable peddlers who have metastasized all over Manhattan,

Alper to Leave

EDC is losing its top official, with Andy Alper announcing his departure from city government yesterday. As far as the Alliance is concerned, our "appraisal", it is addition by subtraction (Shakespeare's line comes to mind: "Nothing became him so much as his leaving"). Once again the city reached into the ranks of big business to find someone to craft its economic development policy and the results were predictable.

Perhaps the low point of Alper's tenure was his handling of the BTM fiasco. When the City Council held its original oversight meeting it was determined that EDC had failed to appraise the value of the House of Detention when it decided to "swap" it for another piece of property controlled by the Related Company.

Not only that. It also came out months later that EDC failed to disclose that the Bronx jail was going to have to be replaced, at a cost of over $300 million. So the original deal, bad to begin with, was actually hundreds of millions of dollars worse.

Which is why we got a kick out of the mayor's comments about the Alper exit: "Andy restructured and professionalized EDC..." Apparently he just forgot to add appraisers to his real estate division.

Monday, May 08, 2006

Tribal Truth

In what has to be a not to be believed situation, the New York State's Indian tribes are "fuming" over the recently filed lawsuit by the convenience store association. The suit would force the governor to actually enforce the law on collecting taxes on all retail outlets that sell cigarettes.

According to a report in today's NY Post Lance Gumbs, a smoke shop owner and member of the Shinnecock Indian nation on Long Island, says that the suit, if successful, would put the tribal shop out of business. "We would shut down" he said; "If our cigarettes are taxed, people will have no incentive to come here, and will go to 7-Eleven."

Well gee whiz! You mean that the folks aren't flocking to the tribal outlets because of their marketing expertise? It seems that the level playing field is exactly what the tribes are afraid of. That shouldn't be any reason for insulating them from the law.

Sunday, May 07, 2006

Oddo Boy!

Kudos to Staten Island councilman and Republican minority leader James Oddo for his spirited defense of his borough against the NASCAR invasion in yesterday's NY Daily News. His opposition was based on the still unaddressed traffic nightmare that would only be exacerbated by the introduction of a race track that would "bring 90,000 people and predicate its traffic plan on moving 25,000 fans in 8,400 vehicles. Then add 1,000 buses and 635 RVs."

Oddo goes on to ridicule the adding of an additional 620,000-square-foot retail center adjacent to the stadium saying, "A strip mall on steroids is not the kind of economic development we need." As Oddo points out, echoing our comments on accountable development, "There is pride in every job, but Island residents need full-time, well-paid jobs that allow them to work and live in the borough."

Saturday, May 06, 2006

Will Shelly Like to Boogie?

Friday's legislative hearing on a bill that Shelly Silver has introduced to cut down on the proliferation of bars and clubs in certain Manhattan neighborhoods was well-attended and boisterous. As the NY Times reported, the hearing "brought out scores of anxious business owners who oppose the measure and an even larger number of residents desperately seeking relief from what they say is a plague of noisy nightlife establishments and their inebriated clientele."

We believe that both parties have strong points but the legislative remedy, as Silver himself acknowledged, "is draconian." One of the bill's biggest problems, as we have pointed out before, is that it would effectively shutdown the expansion of the industry in certain areas, even those neighborhoods where complaints have been minimal. As one restauranteur said, "This law is punitive...It's going to hurt so many mom and pop entrepreneurs."

There is no doubt that some neighborhoods are under seige but the answer may lie with enforcement rather than blanket legislation. The Alliance knows since we have often worked with neighborhoods to rid the community of late night menaces. In Brooklyn we helped evict Ram Caterers that was operating late into the night out of a synogogue on Ocean Parkway. Existing law needs to be, and can be, vigorously enforced if a bar or club is unduly disturbing a neighborhood.

In addition, as the Times points out, if a community gets together it can force the State Liquor Authority to turn down an exemption to the so-called 500 foot law. Once again, the Alliance did just that in Chelsea as we stopped a club from opening on 17th Street next to Shadow Studios six years ago. As the SLA told the Times, "...when it comes to exemptions challenged by the community, it often sides with opponents. Daniel Boyle, the authority's chairman said that so far this year in Manhattan, the agency had rejected 7 of 10 applicants who faced local opposition.

A proper balance needs to be struck between neighborhoods seeking some peace and quiet and a bill that, in the words of Christyne Nichols, president of NYC and Company, "could drastically hinder our ability to bring future business for New York City." It is definitely time for statesmanship.

Friday, May 05, 2006

NYC's Planned Shrinkage

It seems to us at the Alliance that the city has a plan to reduce the number 0f supermarkets and other food retailers in town. We say this because there has been absolutely no effort to cut down on the wave of food peddlers that are brazenly setting up directly in front of the city's supermarkets and grocery stores. In the process, hundreds of thousands of dollars are being siphoned away from tax paying retailers.

The latest in a series of fiascos took place yesterday on the corner of 115th Street and Broadway. In an attempt to do something to protect his business Morton Williams, owner of the adjacent MortonWilliams Associated Supermarket, place a "first amendment" table right in the spot that a persistent fruit peddler has staked out in an attempt to intercept the traffic that the market itself generates.

What did the peddler do? Why he called the police and along came Officer Harper who told the store manager to remove his table because "this vendor has a permit for 115th Street and Broadway." In the process the officer, acting on what impulse we have no idea, violated two sections of the municipal code.

There is no food vending license in the City of New York that is site-specific. In addition, in any area where vending is permitted first amendment vendors have an absolute right to set up shop on the street. What motivated Officer Harper? It certainly wasn't a respect for the law.

There's a larger issue here. It is the total disrespect that too many of our elected officials have for hard-working, tax paying, store owners. This is the mindset that encourages out-of-town farmers to come into the city to take business away from neighborhood retailers.

In fact Community Board #4 in Manhattan has just approved a farmer's market for Tenth Avenue right around the corner from a Food Emporium. Board members told the store rep that the market would increase Food Emporium's business! Clearly economics is not the Board's strong suit but our greater worry is the cavalier disregard for the city's tax base. When all the supermarkets are gone from Hell's Kitchen will the Board pass a resolution calling on the city to incentivize their return?

The romanticizing of the food peddler needs to stop. We have been busy working with members of the City Council in the drafting of legislation that would put these folks under a stricter regulatory structure. The city needs to act on this quickly and, if there is a concern for getting people to eat in a more healthy manner, than it's important to create a partnership between the food stores and the public sector to address the issue.

Thursday, May 04, 2006

Post: Mike Needs to Calm Down on Eminent Domain

The NY Post editorializes today on the mayor’s recent policy statement on eminent domain saying that while eminent domain is needed in certain instances the mayor’s unsubtle viewpoint is unwarranted. This piggybacks on our comments yesterday.