The total lack of any realistic option for the more appropriate disposal of commercial waste in the city's SWMP is also underscored by the inevitable failure of the proposed 59th Street facility. As the NY Daily News reports this morning, "Council insiders and Manhattan community and political leaders contend that the three borough facilities in the plan {Gansevoort and East 91st Street} are doomed to be non-starters, because of litigation or Albany legislative opposition."
So, when these puzzle pieces prove to be unavailable what has the mayor and the council actually done for the beleaguered waterfront communities?" Very quickly, in same time next year fashion, we'll be back to square one. As usual the failure to actually come up with a waste-reduction strategy will bring us back to the same, same old. The fair share plan will be reduced to a continuation of the city's expensive "pump and dump" landfill based methodology.
Which brings us back to the logic of Intro 133, the measure that would study the utility of installing commercial food waste disposers. In today's Crain's In$ider the newsletter reports on the Alliance's continued efforts to win the support of Speaker Quinn for a bill that has 35 council sponsors.
The Insider points out that the DEP and WM are in opposition, and cites a grinder supporter who speculates that WM's opposition may be a result of the fact that the company's "revenues would suffer if businesses could grind up food rubbish rather than pay them to remove it." But on further reflection perhaps this is the source of the city's opposition as well.
If, as we speculated in the previous post the city is looking to flow control commercial waste, than it wouldn't be in its interest to develop a method that would remove the cash cow of organic waste before it reached city controlled transfer stations. It certainly wouldn't be the first time that a public bureaucracy colluded with the interests of a multi-billion contractor.
As we continue to watch all of this unfold we anticipate that the mayor's efforts to appear good rather than to actually be good will flounder and the entire SWMP will unravel. This is precisely what makes the pilot program for food waste disposers so important.
Wednesday, July 19, 2006
Whither Commercial Trash?
One of the unresolved issues that the city's SWMP fails to adequately address is the fate of the roughly 12,000 tons of daily commercial garbage produced by this town's businesses. The building of a transfer station on West 59th Street is supposed to siphon off a good portion of Manhattan's commercial waste that is currently being sent to Brooklyn and the Bronx, and the other stations are supposed to take some private garbage as well.
Left unsaid, however, is the fact that the city has no ability to force private carters to dump anywhere it tells them to. This is the subject of a piece ($) in this week's Crain's New York Business where author Erik Engquist points out that the private waste haulers not only have no incentive to divert their garbage to a city-owned facility, they are also convinced that it will inevitably be more costly to do it.
Crain's quotes one of our old friends, carter Dominick Incantalupo, saying, "It would send costs through the roof...They could effectively double my tipping fee." He goes on to point out that these added costs would have to be passed on to his customers.
Given these facts it is clear, as Sanitation Chair Mike McMahon points out, "haulers won't use the proposed transfer stations unless the city subsidizes the cost." In addition, if the city tries to mandate their use (called "flow control") a court battle will be inevitable, and carters have won most of these in the past.
Of course as Engquist highlights the city could come down in a draconian fashion on the existing private transfer stations by "strictly" enforcing environmental codes, thereby making it more costly to operate these stations. This is exactly the scenario that we have been predicting: the city builds expensive marine transfer stations, effectively puts the private ones out of business, and then forces the local businesses to subsidize the cost of all the city's garbage removal.
This is not the result that that well recognized expert on garbage costs, Partnership president Kathryn Wylde, feels will happen. Wylde believes that the mayor's plan "would actually lower trash-hauling fees." As she told Crain's, "Each new transfer station has additional capacity for the commercial haulers...That should give the carters more options and overall lower costs."
This is a totally irresponsible statement from the head of a group whose mission is to promote the interests of the city's business community. In the first place, her view of the laws of supply and demand are simply inapplicable to an industry that not only is controlled by an oligopoly but one where the city is in charge if setting rates.
If NYC controls, along with WM, the tipping and export of commercial waste there simply is no free market at work to lower costs. As Incantalupo cogently points out, "My clients will end up having to pay."
Left unsaid, however, is the fact that the city has no ability to force private carters to dump anywhere it tells them to. This is the subject of a piece ($) in this week's Crain's New York Business where author Erik Engquist points out that the private waste haulers not only have no incentive to divert their garbage to a city-owned facility, they are also convinced that it will inevitably be more costly to do it.
Crain's quotes one of our old friends, carter Dominick Incantalupo, saying, "It would send costs through the roof...They could effectively double my tipping fee." He goes on to point out that these added costs would have to be passed on to his customers.
Given these facts it is clear, as Sanitation Chair Mike McMahon points out, "haulers won't use the proposed transfer stations unless the city subsidizes the cost." In addition, if the city tries to mandate their use (called "flow control") a court battle will be inevitable, and carters have won most of these in the past.
Of course as Engquist highlights the city could come down in a draconian fashion on the existing private transfer stations by "strictly" enforcing environmental codes, thereby making it more costly to operate these stations. This is exactly the scenario that we have been predicting: the city builds expensive marine transfer stations, effectively puts the private ones out of business, and then forces the local businesses to subsidize the cost of all the city's garbage removal.
This is not the result that that well recognized expert on garbage costs, Partnership president Kathryn Wylde, feels will happen. Wylde believes that the mayor's plan "would actually lower trash-hauling fees." As she told Crain's, "Each new transfer station has additional capacity for the commercial haulers...That should give the carters more options and overall lower costs."
This is a totally irresponsible statement from the head of a group whose mission is to promote the interests of the city's business community. In the first place, her view of the laws of supply and demand are simply inapplicable to an industry that not only is controlled by an oligopoly but one where the city is in charge if setting rates.
If NYC controls, along with WM, the tipping and export of commercial waste there simply is no free market at work to lower costs. As Incantalupo cogently points out, "My clients will end up having to pay."
Tuesday, July 18, 2006
Council to Take Out the Garbage
As the Times is reporting this morning it appears that the City Council is poised to pass the SWMP at its Stated Meeting tomorrow. It also appears that, aside from some minor adjustments, the plan will reflect the substance of the mayor's original proposal.
One of the unresolved issues according to the Times is the question of "setting a long-range goal for reducing the 50,000 tons of commercial and residential trash produced in the city every day." This reflects what we have been saying all along about the plan's lack of any credible waste reduction strategy.
What needs to be done is for the Council to move swiftly, after passing the mayor's plan, to implement Intro 133, the pilot program for the use of commercial food waste disposers. It should also examine the expansion of the use of residential disposers so that the city can (as "Zero Waste" spokesperson Jean Halloran says) "reduce our waste exports." The city might also at the same time be able to obviate the need to build an expensive an obtrusive commercial waste transfer station at 59th Street in Manhattan.
One of the unresolved issues according to the Times is the question of "setting a long-range goal for reducing the 50,000 tons of commercial and residential trash produced in the city every day." This reflects what we have been saying all along about the plan's lack of any credible waste reduction strategy.
What needs to be done is for the Council to move swiftly, after passing the mayor's plan, to implement Intro 133, the pilot program for the use of commercial food waste disposers. It should also examine the expansion of the use of residential disposers so that the city can (as "Zero Waste" spokesperson Jean Halloran says) "reduce our waste exports." The city might also at the same time be able to obviate the need to build an expensive an obtrusive commercial waste transfer station at 59th Street in Manhattan.
Wal-Mart Rings in New York
In today's NY Sun the paper continues to report on the apparent attempt of Wal-Mart to effectively ring the outskirts of NYC with stores. Stymied by City Council leadership and the efforts of the anti Wal-Mart coalition, the retailer has been unable to break into the lucrative city market. This time the store is in White Plains and it is somewhat different from the store's normal format in that it is supposed to have an "urban design" element.
What this attempt means for the city is rather murky it seems to us. It reminds us somewhat of the attempt by Costco to create a new urban model called "Costco Fresh," a multi-story store with little or no parking in the heart of the West Side of Manhattan. This idea was soundly slam-dunked by Chris Quinn and Tom Duane over 6 years ago and we don't think Wal-Mart will do any better with its variant.
The White Plains store will have a parking garage and we don't think it would be practical to replicate this in the heart of Manhattan or in Downtown Brooklyn, as one newspaper has advocated. Which leaves the retailer with the same site fight issues that plagued it in Rego Park and now stall its efforts in Tottenville.
The reality is that Wal-Mart will need to try to find an "as-of=right" site if it wants to make headway in NYC. Any other effort will be uphill all the way.
What this attempt means for the city is rather murky it seems to us. It reminds us somewhat of the attempt by Costco to create a new urban model called "Costco Fresh," a multi-story store with little or no parking in the heart of the West Side of Manhattan. This idea was soundly slam-dunked by Chris Quinn and Tom Duane over 6 years ago and we don't think Wal-Mart will do any better with its variant.
The White Plains store will have a parking garage and we don't think it would be practical to replicate this in the heart of Manhattan or in Downtown Brooklyn, as one newspaper has advocated. Which leaves the retailer with the same site fight issues that plagued it in Rego Park and now stall its efforts in Tottenville.
The reality is that Wal-Mart will need to try to find an "as-of=right" site if it wants to make headway in NYC. Any other effort will be uphill all the way.
Monday, July 17, 2006
Atlantic Yards and The Spanish Civil War
The DDD people can out yesterday in Brooklyn and, depending on who you ask, generated somewhere between 2,000 and 4,000 folks to a rally against AY. If you accept the lower Times estimate there were more people who came out last week to an informal forum of FCRC to discuss the affordable housing opportunities at the development.
We're not surprised (and hold the comments on how Richard Lipsky represents FCRC-stick to the arguments please). While the DDD have done a valiant job at organizing their rear guard action it will inevitably prove to be insufficient because of the need for new housing and the passionate support from Brooklyn ballers for the Nets.
Which brings us to the title of today's post. The satirist Tom Lehrer, writing a song about the Spanish Civil War said it best: "Remember the war against Franco, that's the kind where each of us belonged. He may have won all the battles. But we had all the good songs."
We're not surprised (and hold the comments on how Richard Lipsky represents FCRC-stick to the arguments please). While the DDD have done a valiant job at organizing their rear guard action it will inevitably prove to be insufficient because of the need for new housing and the passionate support from Brooklyn ballers for the Nets.
Which brings us to the title of today's post. The satirist Tom Lehrer, writing a song about the Spanish Civil War said it best: "Remember the war against Franco, that's the kind where each of us belonged. He may have won all the battles. But we had all the good songs."
Poverty, Jobs and Economic Development
The NY Times is reporting today that the mayor is about to embark on his own "War on Poverty." He has set up a commission to attack the problem of poverty in this city. As Linda Gibbs, deputy mayor for health and human services (is this the right porfolio for this work?) explains, the focus is "what we can do to direct investments im poor households in a way that improves their earning capacity."
Hold on to your wallets everyone, "We're from the government and we're here to help you." As the Times points out; "The effort is not without minefields. Mr. Bloomberg has charged the commission with finding ways to diminish or eradicate poverty without significantly increasing the size or cost of government."
Ho! Ho! We've heard this mantra before and the results are predictable. The mindset and approach pretty much insures that the only real beneficiaries will be the service providers. Just take a look at the members of the commission. Old government hands and academics along with one time-honored member of the permanent government, the venerable Bill Rudin. Not a single small businessman or, God forbid, an economist like E. J. McMahon. Just a round up of all the old Good Society types who misread the problem in the past.
Which brings us to the previous comments that we have made about this mayor's basic economic philosophy. He simply does not see the correlation between the size of government, over regulation and taxes and job growth.
In today's NY Post Steve Malanga of the Manhattan Institute makes the point (and why is no one from here included on the panel?) that the city's relatively poor job growth is the direct result of its record nearly $2 billion real estate tax increase in 2002. This tax, passed on directly to each and every retailer in this city, when combined with increased fines and fees, is the direct cause of the city's poor job development.
Today the city's relatively robust wage picture is a feature of one or two high income sectors, insuring, as Malanga says, that "the city's tax base is also growing ever narrower." Not everyone, however, is as gloomy as Steve. In today's Times our good friend, and Bloomberg toady, Mitch Moss writes a letter that started our day off with a good chuckle.
As Moss and his collaborator point out, New York "is not in a jobless recovery, but New Yorkers are deriving their income from a variety of sources." As they go on to tell us, intrepid New Yorkers are simply relying on "the strength of the cash-based underground economy."
So, "Thank God for the peddlers!" We don't need to worry about job loss because "immigrant entrepreneurs" are flooding the city's streets with pushcarts. New York doesn't need a poverty commission. It needs an economic development policy that understands the correlation between job growth, tax relief and less government regulation.
Hold on to your wallets everyone, "We're from the government and we're here to help you." As the Times points out; "The effort is not without minefields. Mr. Bloomberg has charged the commission with finding ways to diminish or eradicate poverty without significantly increasing the size or cost of government."
Ho! Ho! We've heard this mantra before and the results are predictable. The mindset and approach pretty much insures that the only real beneficiaries will be the service providers. Just take a look at the members of the commission. Old government hands and academics along with one time-honored member of the permanent government, the venerable Bill Rudin. Not a single small businessman or, God forbid, an economist like E. J. McMahon. Just a round up of all the old Good Society types who misread the problem in the past.
Which brings us to the previous comments that we have made about this mayor's basic economic philosophy. He simply does not see the correlation between the size of government, over regulation and taxes and job growth.
In today's NY Post Steve Malanga of the Manhattan Institute makes the point (and why is no one from here included on the panel?) that the city's relatively poor job growth is the direct result of its record nearly $2 billion real estate tax increase in 2002. This tax, passed on directly to each and every retailer in this city, when combined with increased fines and fees, is the direct cause of the city's poor job development.
Today the city's relatively robust wage picture is a feature of one or two high income sectors, insuring, as Malanga says, that "the city's tax base is also growing ever narrower." Not everyone, however, is as gloomy as Steve. In today's Times our good friend, and Bloomberg toady, Mitch Moss writes a letter that started our day off with a good chuckle.
As Moss and his collaborator point out, New York "is not in a jobless recovery, but New Yorkers are deriving their income from a variety of sources." As they go on to tell us, intrepid New Yorkers are simply relying on "the strength of the cash-based underground economy."
So, "Thank God for the peddlers!" We don't need to worry about job loss because "immigrant entrepreneurs" are flooding the city's streets with pushcarts. New York doesn't need a poverty commission. It needs an economic development policy that understands the correlation between job growth, tax relief and less government regulation.
Friday, July 14, 2006
Oozing Out of the SWMP
The NY Daily News is reporting today that the City Council is slated to vote on the mayor's SWMP next Wednesday. Negotiations are ongoing and there's still a possibility that the vote will be postponed. The question of what to do with the Manhattan transfer facilities is still the major sticking point.
We believe that the Council will pass the plan as is, leaving the issue of the legality of the controversial sites up to the courts. In this way the Speaker will have delivered for the mayor on a key policy and the failure of the siting, if that's what transpires, will be on someone else's shoulders. Key council members have told us that they believe that the two West Side transfer stations will be killed because they will require state legislative approval (the Hudson River Park Conservancy issue), something that's just not going to happen.
If this all goes according to this scenario, the resolution of the commercial waste problem will, once again, be left unresolved. Of course, the use of commercial food waste disposers would go along way toward mooting the necessity of 59th Street altogether. We're still hopeful that the Council will move in this direction in the Fall.
We believe that the Council will pass the plan as is, leaving the issue of the legality of the controversial sites up to the courts. In this way the Speaker will have delivered for the mayor on a key policy and the failure of the siting, if that's what transpires, will be on someone else's shoulders. Key council members have told us that they believe that the two West Side transfer stations will be killed because they will require state legislative approval (the Hudson River Park Conservancy issue), something that's just not going to happen.
If this all goes according to this scenario, the resolution of the commercial waste problem will, once again, be left unresolved. Of course, the use of commercial food waste disposers would go along way toward mooting the necessity of 59th Street altogether. We're still hopeful that the Council will move in this direction in the Fall.
Cigarettes Kill
We have been railing against the blatant violation of law by two Long Island Indian tribes in the sale of buttlegged cigarettes. Our point has been that the butts end up being sold on the streets of the city and, therefore, hurting legitimate store owners. Dealers have also been killed fighting over territory on New York's streets. The situation has led to a lawsuit by the Gristedes supermarket chain against the tribes.
Now, however, the situation has deteriorated with the murder of a rival buttlegger upset with the loss of some of his lucrative business. All of which makes the refusal of Governor George Pataki to enforce the existing tax laws even more egregious. One wonders just what kind of impact the governor thinks his refusal to enforce duly passed laws will have on conservative Republican primary voters.
The only explanation here is that the money trail here must be extremely lucrative (Certainly the stated fear of Indian violence is just a ruse).Why else would a "conservative" governor refuse to enforce the law?
Now, however, the situation has deteriorated with the murder of a rival buttlegger upset with the loss of some of his lucrative business. All of which makes the refusal of Governor George Pataki to enforce the existing tax laws even more egregious. One wonders just what kind of impact the governor thinks his refusal to enforce duly passed laws will have on conservative Republican primary voters.
The only explanation here is that the money trail here must be extremely lucrative (Certainly the stated fear of Indian violence is just a ruse).Why else would a "conservative" governor refuse to enforce the law?
Thursday, July 13, 2006
Zero Waste? Not in the Municipal Bureaucracy
In yesterday's Crain's In$ider the newsletter reported that a coalition of "commercial, environmental and consumer groups" were winning support for their "zero waste" program through their support of the city's SWMP. The program features a full panoply of waste reduction strategies as well as the creation of a separate office of waste prevention that would include "direct education to inform communities about recycling."
While we do disagree with a good deal of what the "Reaching For Zero" report outlines, there are aspects of the proposal that are meritorious. In particular, the report states clearly that it is not prudent for the city to continue its open-ended expense of simply exporting garbage to other jurisdictions. The costs it is rightfully argued are "primarily the result of increasing costs of landfills and believed to be at least partly due to the increased consolidation in the waste industry, leaving a few companies controlling most disposal facilities."
The Zero authors also correctly point out that these escalating costs are "clearly untenable for the long term." In place of the never ending landfill future, however, zero wasters propose a comprehensive waste reduction program that would establish a command recycling economy with a fully staffed government bureaucracy to run it.
In addition, they propose a far-reaching composting for food waste that exposes the impractical nature of the authors' mindset. They also outline new legal strictures to insure that the private sector follows government mandated recycling standards. As part of the composting plan they envision the distribution of 50,000 "backyard bins" and a "public task force" to advise the city on "compost facility siting."
The coalition of groups behind the zero waste plan do not have anyone with any real knowledge of basic economics nor is there any visible public policy expertise that analyzes the costs and benefits of such a massive government controlled waste reduction structure.
The plan is also fraught with danger for the city's retail businesses who will be subject to the whims of people whose backgrounds indicate that they are at best indifferent and at worse hostile to the concerns of the city's private sector. The exclusion of any discussion of commercial food waste disposers, and the advocacy of the "bigger better bottle bill," only underscores this indifference and hostility.
The City of New York drastically needs to devise alternatives to exporting and landfilling its waste. The "Reaching for Zero" coalition offers a retrograde and expensive alternative that, while failing to really get to the root of effective waste reduction, will set in motion a government bureaucracy that will wreck havoc on the city's commercial sector.
While we do disagree with a good deal of what the "Reaching For Zero" report outlines, there are aspects of the proposal that are meritorious. In particular, the report states clearly that it is not prudent for the city to continue its open-ended expense of simply exporting garbage to other jurisdictions. The costs it is rightfully argued are "primarily the result of increasing costs of landfills and believed to be at least partly due to the increased consolidation in the waste industry, leaving a few companies controlling most disposal facilities."
The Zero authors also correctly point out that these escalating costs are "clearly untenable for the long term." In place of the never ending landfill future, however, zero wasters propose a comprehensive waste reduction program that would establish a command recycling economy with a fully staffed government bureaucracy to run it.
In addition, they propose a far-reaching composting for food waste that exposes the impractical nature of the authors' mindset. They also outline new legal strictures to insure that the private sector follows government mandated recycling standards. As part of the composting plan they envision the distribution of 50,000 "backyard bins" and a "public task force" to advise the city on "compost facility siting."
The coalition of groups behind the zero waste plan do not have anyone with any real knowledge of basic economics nor is there any visible public policy expertise that analyzes the costs and benefits of such a massive government controlled waste reduction structure.
The plan is also fraught with danger for the city's retail businesses who will be subject to the whims of people whose backgrounds indicate that they are at best indifferent and at worse hostile to the concerns of the city's private sector. The exclusion of any discussion of commercial food waste disposers, and the advocacy of the "bigger better bottle bill," only underscores this indifference and hostility.
The City of New York drastically needs to devise alternatives to exporting and landfilling its waste. The "Reaching for Zero" coalition offers a retrograde and expensive alternative that, while failing to really get to the root of effective waste reduction, will set in motion a government bureaucracy that will wreck havoc on the city's commercial sector.
Zoning: Fast Food Facts
In today's Crain's In$ider there is a post done on the proposal by Councilman Rivera to use the zoning laws to restrict the proliferation of fast food outlets. In the view of Crain's the research done on the issue at The Bloomberg School of Public Health demonstrates that zoning hasn't been use to address obesity but only to "enhance neighborhoods' aesthetic appeals." The heading on the post reads, "Fast-food fight data muddied up."
That conclusion, however, is unwarranted. What the study underscores is that the use of zoning to restrict fast food has been done all over the country on the basis of "community character" concerns, a basis that the authors feel is much less substantial and justifiable than an underlying concern with obesity.
The premise here is that the real justification for any zoning legislation hinges primarily on the police powers of a municipality. Historically health and safety concerns have been the primary variable, under the rubric of police powers, that have been cited for justifying any zoning changes. In fact the first comprehensive zoning laws were enacted in 1916 by New York City precisely to address health issues that were attendant to both the pervasiveness of slum housing as well as the proximity of residential buildings to more noxious industrial uses.
In other words zoning has always been about health and safety and the authors of the report (a collaboration of Hopkins public health folks and Georgetown law professors) are saying very clearly that if fast food outlets can be restricted on the basis of community character, with the restrictions being upheld by the courts, than the more serious health rationales should be able to withstand any legal challenge.
That conclusion, however, is unwarranted. What the study underscores is that the use of zoning to restrict fast food has been done all over the country on the basis of "community character" concerns, a basis that the authors feel is much less substantial and justifiable than an underlying concern with obesity.
The premise here is that the real justification for any zoning legislation hinges primarily on the police powers of a municipality. Historically health and safety concerns have been the primary variable, under the rubric of police powers, that have been cited for justifying any zoning changes. In fact the first comprehensive zoning laws were enacted in 1916 by New York City precisely to address health issues that were attendant to both the pervasiveness of slum housing as well as the proximity of residential buildings to more noxious industrial uses.
In other words zoning has always been about health and safety and the authors of the report (a collaboration of Hopkins public health folks and Georgetown law professors) are saying very clearly that if fast food outlets can be restricted on the basis of community character, with the restrictions being upheld by the courts, than the more serious health rationales should be able to withstand any legal challenge.
Wednesday, July 12, 2006
One Down One to Go
Last night the Yonkers City Council approved, by a 5-2 vote, the zoning permissions necessary to build the controversial Ridge Hill Village development. The approval came after a three year battle waged by those civic groups closest to the project. As to be expected the concerns rested on the traffic impacts of the $600 million mixed use development.
The Alliance's Richard Lipsky has been working with the developer, Forest City Ratner, in an effort to develop a grass roots support for the plan. As a result, a coalition of parents and teacher groups did come together in support for Ridge Hill. These groups were motivated not only by the opportunity that the project presented to significantly increase badly needed tax revenues for the City of Yonkers, but also by the developer's commitment to become a stakeholder for the improvement of Yonkers schools.
What this demonstrated is that grass roots lobbying is a tool that can be used both for and against a development and real estate firms need to learn to use this vehicle to insure political support for their developments. If done correctly, and assuming that there are enough public benefits in the project, this kind of effort can be not only effective but can legitimately be a vehicle to underscore how a development benefits a wider public (especially when a nearby community group that is opposed to the plan gets a great deal of media attention).
What struck us in this battle was the peculiar nature of Yonkers politics. Standard methods and expectations seemed to be absent and strategies needed to be constantly revised. A great deal of credit needs to go to the united front presented by all of the organized labor groups in Yonkers. Their presence was an essential countervailing force to the determined civic opposition. Also kudos to FCRC's Bruce Bender who showed the foresight to put all these forces together.
That is why we were bemused to watch the News 12 Westchester report on last night's meeting. The television reporter claimed that, "While a few people did voice positive opinions, they were largely booed by those in attendance." This is as far from the truth as possible since at least 75% of those at the meeting were supporters of Ridge Hill. In fact the real story was how small a turnout the despirited opposition was able to bring to their last hurrah (Only 100 people in all came out and if there was any booing it was mostly the union folks supplying the passion).
What this all means is that the City of Yonkers will be able to move forward with a badly needed redevelopment plan. We expect that FCRC will move quickly to take a role in the education battles on behalf of Yonkers school kids that certainly lie ahead. When this happens an even greater win-win for Yonkers will become a reality.
The Alliance's Richard Lipsky has been working with the developer, Forest City Ratner, in an effort to develop a grass roots support for the plan. As a result, a coalition of parents and teacher groups did come together in support for Ridge Hill. These groups were motivated not only by the opportunity that the project presented to significantly increase badly needed tax revenues for the City of Yonkers, but also by the developer's commitment to become a stakeholder for the improvement of Yonkers schools.
What this demonstrated is that grass roots lobbying is a tool that can be used both for and against a development and real estate firms need to learn to use this vehicle to insure political support for their developments. If done correctly, and assuming that there are enough public benefits in the project, this kind of effort can be not only effective but can legitimately be a vehicle to underscore how a development benefits a wider public (especially when a nearby community group that is opposed to the plan gets a great deal of media attention).
What struck us in this battle was the peculiar nature of Yonkers politics. Standard methods and expectations seemed to be absent and strategies needed to be constantly revised. A great deal of credit needs to go to the united front presented by all of the organized labor groups in Yonkers. Their presence was an essential countervailing force to the determined civic opposition. Also kudos to FCRC's Bruce Bender who showed the foresight to put all these forces together.
That is why we were bemused to watch the News 12 Westchester report on last night's meeting. The television reporter claimed that, "While a few people did voice positive opinions, they were largely booed by those in attendance." This is as far from the truth as possible since at least 75% of those at the meeting were supporters of Ridge Hill. In fact the real story was how small a turnout the despirited opposition was able to bring to their last hurrah (Only 100 people in all came out and if there was any booing it was mostly the union folks supplying the passion).
What this all means is that the City of Yonkers will be able to move forward with a badly needed redevelopment plan. We expect that FCRC will move quickly to take a role in the education battles on behalf of Yonkers school kids that certainly lie ahead. When this happens an even greater win-win for Yonkers will become a reality.
Tuesday, July 11, 2006
Finding Wasteland
Crain's also mentions the efforts of the Durst Organization to "consider other locations for a commercial waste-transfer station proposed for West 59th Street at the Hudson River." This is all quite understandable, given the real estate firms holdings in the immediate area, but it begs the overall waste reduction issue that we have been stressing.
What we do know with some degree of confidence, and former sanitation commissioner and Durst consultant Sexton has a clear picture of this, is that the extensive deployment of food waste disposers, particularly in restaurant-rich Manhattan, will so dramatically reduce commercial waste that it is probable that an additional commercial transfer station would not be necessary. That is what all concerned should be looking closely at as the SWMP is being considered.
What we do know with some degree of confidence, and former sanitation commissioner and Durst consultant Sexton has a clear picture of this, is that the extensive deployment of food waste disposers, particularly in restaurant-rich Manhattan, will so dramatically reduce commercial waste that it is probable that an additional commercial transfer station would not be necessary. That is what all concerned should be looking closely at as the SWMP is being considered.
Insider's Props to Rivera
Crain's In$ider has a post today on the newly elevated stature of City Council Health Committee chair, Joel Rivera. As Crain's points out, "Some insiders had doubted that City Councilman Joel Rivera, D-Bronx, would be an effective health committee chairman when he inherited the post from Christine Quinn... But Rivera is moving to establish himself as a fighter of obesity, particularly among children and minorities."
Crain's goes on to talk about Rivera's zoning suggestion but also mentions the councilman's funding of Dr. Oz's Health Corps program in three new schools this fall. Clearly, this is an issue that will give Rivera a good platform from which to launch a bid to become Bronx BP in 2009.
Crain's goes on to talk about Rivera's zoning suggestion but also mentions the councilman's funding of Dr. Oz's Health Corps program in three new schools this fall. Clearly, this is an issue that will give Rivera a good platform from which to launch a bid to become Bronx BP in 2009.
Chambers to Meet on Wal-Mart
Tomorrow night there will be a meeting of the newly formed Ramapo Jewish Chamber of Commerce at Eli's Bagels on Maple Avenue in Spring Valley. The meeting will feature a traffic presentation by the Alliance's Brian Ketcham who will critique the projected scope of work being proposed by the consultants for the Wal-Mart in Monsey. Members of the Spring Valley Chamber of Commerce will also join the group.
The Chamber, led by Monsey business consultant Abe Stauber, is rapidly signing up members who are concerned about the super center's impact on their stores. The Monsey scope has now included the socio-economic impacts that it first tried to avoid. As we have pointed out previously, lawyer Dennis Lynch represents a group that will commission its own economic impact study.
One of the keys for us is to help the Planning Board understand more fully the collateral damages of the development. What this means is understanding the full extent to which the local retailers contribute to the economic and social vitality of the surrounding community. This understanding necessitates that any analyst examine the extent to which local business contributes a "multiplyer effect" to the community's economy.
In addition, particularly in regard to the Monsey businesses, the evaluation should include the level of cross-pollination between the business owners and Monsey and New Square religious and cultural institutions. One thing we know for sure-Wal-Mart, unlike the Monsey business community, will not be donating money to places like the Yeshiva of Spring Valley. We'll have more on this topic at a later date.
The Chamber, led by Monsey business consultant Abe Stauber, is rapidly signing up members who are concerned about the super center's impact on their stores. The Monsey scope has now included the socio-economic impacts that it first tried to avoid. As we have pointed out previously, lawyer Dennis Lynch represents a group that will commission its own economic impact study.
One of the keys for us is to help the Planning Board understand more fully the collateral damages of the development. What this means is understanding the full extent to which the local retailers contribute to the economic and social vitality of the surrounding community. This understanding necessitates that any analyst examine the extent to which local business contributes a "multiplyer effect" to the community's economy.
In addition, particularly in regard to the Monsey businesses, the evaluation should include the level of cross-pollination between the business owners and Monsey and New Square religious and cultural institutions. One thing we know for sure-Wal-Mart, unlike the Monsey business community, will not be donating money to places like the Yeshiva of Spring Valley. We'll have more on this topic at a later date.
Railroaded?
We couldn't resist commenting on the mayor's efforts to get the MTA to sell the Hudson Rail Yards to the city for the bargain price of $300 million. Why do we still get the feeling that the mayor sees all this property, much like he saw the BTM site, as the back forty of the Bloomberg ranch?
Eliot Spitzer is right. The city needs to put the land up for competitive bid. After that, the uses can be controlled by the mayor and the speaker through the normal land use review process. All of this, just like the Willets Point development could benefit from greater transparency. One thing is certain the private sector needs to be involved more than government if the area is to developed anytime soon.
Eliot Spitzer is right. The city needs to put the land up for competitive bid. After that, the uses can be controlled by the mayor and the speaker through the normal land use review process. All of this, just like the Willets Point development could benefit from greater transparency. One thing is certain the private sector needs to be involved more than government if the area is to developed anytime soon.
Monday, July 10, 2006
What is Food Justice?
On Friday our friends at DMI posted an interesting piece on "food justice" in NYC. They are one of the few commentators to give Joel Rivera some props for his suggestion that the city explore using zoning to curb fast food outlets. They also praise Congresswoman Nydia Velasquez for her "Bodegas as Catalysts for Healthy Living Act, " a bill that would provide SBA grants to groups willing "to work with bodegas to create healthy food inventories."
We are especially heartened by DMI's criticism of the ridicule that some heaped on Rivera-"most of whom probably don't live in low-income areas." The Institute also pointedly surveys the eating choices in many of these neighborhoods and opines, "it's a wonder that more people are not lying along Nostrand Avenue or 125th Street leaking grease and sugar from various parts of their bodies."
What we do take issue with, however, is the characterization of neighborhood food shopping as a health wasteland. As we have said before there needs to be more recognition of the incredible success story represented by the independent supermarkets of this city. In addition, it isn't appropriate to try to contrast the number of supermarkets in high income areas with the number in poorer districts. The amount of disposable income is a key varuable that must be factored into the equation.
The point about Rivera's zoning suggestion is that it is based on what we would call the Gresham's law of food shopping: bad food choices drive out good food choices. The proliferation of poor eating choices makes it hard for better alternatives to flourish.
The reality is that fast food outlets, backed as they are by the public financial markets, are at a competitive advantage versus locally owned food stores, who are increasingly priced out of areas by escalating commercial rents. The proliferation of chain drug stores in the city has also added to this lamentable situation by pushing out neighborhood supermarkets with their ability to pay higher rents.
Maybe what NYC needs is some kind of inner city food initiative (like in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania) that, along with financial incentives for supermarkets to invest in certain areas, also comes with some healthy eating performance goals as a prerequisite for the aid. By all means, though, the best public policy strategy is to encourage local economic growth and place some restraint on chain store growth.
We are especially heartened by DMI's criticism of the ridicule that some heaped on Rivera-"most of whom probably don't live in low-income areas." The Institute also pointedly surveys the eating choices in many of these neighborhoods and opines, "it's a wonder that more people are not lying along Nostrand Avenue or 125th Street leaking grease and sugar from various parts of their bodies."
What we do take issue with, however, is the characterization of neighborhood food shopping as a health wasteland. As we have said before there needs to be more recognition of the incredible success story represented by the independent supermarkets of this city. In addition, it isn't appropriate to try to contrast the number of supermarkets in high income areas with the number in poorer districts. The amount of disposable income is a key varuable that must be factored into the equation.
The point about Rivera's zoning suggestion is that it is based on what we would call the Gresham's law of food shopping: bad food choices drive out good food choices. The proliferation of poor eating choices makes it hard for better alternatives to flourish.
The reality is that fast food outlets, backed as they are by the public financial markets, are at a competitive advantage versus locally owned food stores, who are increasingly priced out of areas by escalating commercial rents. The proliferation of chain drug stores in the city has also added to this lamentable situation by pushing out neighborhood supermarkets with their ability to pay higher rents.
Maybe what NYC needs is some kind of inner city food initiative (like in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania) that, along with financial incentives for supermarkets to invest in certain areas, also comes with some healthy eating performance goals as a prerequisite for the aid. By all means, though, the best public policy strategy is to encourage local economic growth and place some restraint on chain store growth.
Post Props for Health Corps
In today's NY Post the paper's Carl Campanile focuses on the innovative approach of the Health Corps to tackling the obesity epidemic (you know the one that Andrew Wolf doesn't think exists). The article details the various techniques developed by Dr. Mehmet Oz to get young people to be aware of their often unhealthy eating and lifestyle habits; and the ways that they can alter these patterns in order to live healthier lives.
Our favorite is Oz's use of diseased organs, lungs blackened from smoking and fatty hearts, in order to "scare straight" the high schoolers. As HC coordinator Leslie Marino told the Post, "The kids take pictures of the organs with their camera phones and think twice about going to McDonald's."
Here is the beginning of an effective fast food awareness program. The HC expands to three schools in the Fall.
Our favorite is Oz's use of diseased organs, lungs blackened from smoking and fatty hearts, in order to "scare straight" the high schoolers. As HC coordinator Leslie Marino told the Post, "The kids take pictures of the organs with their camera phones and think twice about going to McDonald's."
Here is the beginning of an effective fast food awareness program. The HC expands to three schools in the Fall.
Waste Not, Want Not-Part 11
In Saturday's NY Times the paper focuses on the four month strike against Waste Management by Local 813 of the Teamsters. Health care and overtime are the two prime issues in the dispute but other policy concerns underlie the entire mess.
There are a number of overriding questions that this labor conflict raises. The first being the fact that, although WM is a private entity, it is garnering over $1 billion in fees handling the city's residential waste out of two transfer station facilities in Brooklyn, and one in Queens and the Bronx. In addition, the company came into this town riding a Giuliani-induced hysteria over the "mob tax" that was supposedly being charged local businesses by private carters linked to organized crime. Shortly after their entry, however, the company joined with two other national firms demanding that the garbage disposal cap, the one designed to return that mob tax to the city's stores and offices, be lifted because it prevented them from making a profit.
Not only that, once WM had garnered the most lucrative transfer stations from the old cartel, they began to systematically divest customers all over the city's neighborhoods. All of which made NY Post columnist Ray Kerrison look like a prophet when, ten years ago, he wrote, "The Hoodlums are Out, But Who's In?"
Don't forget that in order for Waste to be able to set up shop in NYC it had to get a waiver from the regulation that prohibited anyone convicted of a felony from obtaining a garbage license here. The waiver was needed because of the company's long rap sheet in other jurisdictions all over the country.
NYC is in the midst of trying to develop a sensible solid waste plan. What everyone agrees is that this task can't be accomplished without considering the 12,000 daily tons of commercial waste along with the 13,ooo tons of residential garbage. Who handles the commercial waste and how it is handled is a matter of public concern. The fact that the administration is planning to continue its "pump and dump" export strategy also factors in here since WM remains central to all of it.
Is WM the kind of company that the city wants to get into bed with long term? This issue transcends the current labor dispute even while the strike raises questions about the firm's integrity. This question is exacerbated by the fact that WM has divested its holdings on Long Island and in Upstate Orange County to companies that we are told would not pass the licensing threshold in NYC.
Which brings us to a final crucial point. The Alliance has been promoting a waste reduction strategy utilizing food waste disposers for the past three years. Some of the opposition has come from environmental groups but the real foot dragging has been institutional. Why, for instance, would DSNY do a commercial waste study without even including disposers in its scope of work?
The question that needs to be asked is, Who benefits from not using food waste disposers? The clear answer is companies like WM that profit from the higher put-through fees generated by the heavier food waste. Scores of public policy studies have exposed the often cozy relations between private sector firms and the municpal bureaucracies that are supposed to regulate them. Should we look any further for the real source of DEP's and DSNY's reluctance to embrace a methodology that will dramatically reduce waste ?
This entire waste disposal policy needs to be thoroughly examined with a critical eye. If it isn't than we might find that the city has allowed itself to be held hostage to an unethical private sector firm that will bleed it for billions in the decades ahead.
There are a number of overriding questions that this labor conflict raises. The first being the fact that, although WM is a private entity, it is garnering over $1 billion in fees handling the city's residential waste out of two transfer station facilities in Brooklyn, and one in Queens and the Bronx. In addition, the company came into this town riding a Giuliani-induced hysteria over the "mob tax" that was supposedly being charged local businesses by private carters linked to organized crime. Shortly after their entry, however, the company joined with two other national firms demanding that the garbage disposal cap, the one designed to return that mob tax to the city's stores and offices, be lifted because it prevented them from making a profit.
Not only that, once WM had garnered the most lucrative transfer stations from the old cartel, they began to systematically divest customers all over the city's neighborhoods. All of which made NY Post columnist Ray Kerrison look like a prophet when, ten years ago, he wrote, "The Hoodlums are Out, But Who's In?"
Don't forget that in order for Waste to be able to set up shop in NYC it had to get a waiver from the regulation that prohibited anyone convicted of a felony from obtaining a garbage license here. The waiver was needed because of the company's long rap sheet in other jurisdictions all over the country.
NYC is in the midst of trying to develop a sensible solid waste plan. What everyone agrees is that this task can't be accomplished without considering the 12,000 daily tons of commercial waste along with the 13,ooo tons of residential garbage. Who handles the commercial waste and how it is handled is a matter of public concern. The fact that the administration is planning to continue its "pump and dump" export strategy also factors in here since WM remains central to all of it.
Is WM the kind of company that the city wants to get into bed with long term? This issue transcends the current labor dispute even while the strike raises questions about the firm's integrity. This question is exacerbated by the fact that WM has divested its holdings on Long Island and in Upstate Orange County to companies that we are told would not pass the licensing threshold in NYC.
Which brings us to a final crucial point. The Alliance has been promoting a waste reduction strategy utilizing food waste disposers for the past three years. Some of the opposition has come from environmental groups but the real foot dragging has been institutional. Why, for instance, would DSNY do a commercial waste study without even including disposers in its scope of work?
The question that needs to be asked is, Who benefits from not using food waste disposers? The clear answer is companies like WM that profit from the higher put-through fees generated by the heavier food waste. Scores of public policy studies have exposed the often cozy relations between private sector firms and the municpal bureaucracies that are supposed to regulate them. Should we look any further for the real source of DEP's and DSNY's reluctance to embrace a methodology that will dramatically reduce waste ?
This entire waste disposal policy needs to be thoroughly examined with a critical eye. If it isn't than we might find that the city has allowed itself to be held hostage to an unethical private sector firm that will bleed it for billions in the decades ahead.
Wal-Mart in Downtown Brooklyn?
The Brooklyn Papers, having spent a good deal of its resources attacking the proposed Atlantic Yards development, now has set its sights on Wal-Mart and, guess what? The paper feels that the store would, unlike the Brooklyn Nets, be a boon for downtown Brooklyn.
If you read the editorial, however, an interesting pattern emerges. The BPs thinks that a Walmonster in Brooklyn would be different from any other store in the chain. In the first place, "Wal-Mart's standard one-level big box store with an endless parking lot won't fit in Downtown."
What about the company's abysmal labor practices? Not to worry says Brooklyn's authentic voice. "This is not Oskaloosa, Iowa; In Brooklyn, Wal-Mart would not find qualified staff willing to work for sub-par wages and sub-par benefits...Brooklyn presents Wal-Mart with the prefect opportunity to face its critics head on by paying fair wages and offering fair benefits."
Oh, so now we get it. Wal-Mart would be a great addition to Downtown Brooklyn if it just transforms itself into something that it isn't-a transit dependent good employer. As Warner Wolf would say, "Give Me a Break!"
And how about the paper's assumption that, "A Wal-Mart drawing shoppers to Downtown could well enhance the profitability of many nearby businesses..." (unlike if it were built on the periphery). Well there's always a first for everything, and this store becoming a business magnet for others when its entire model is based on eliminating competitors, would break new ground.
So what we end up with is the Brooklyn Papers' offering the borough a classic "pig in a poke." Expecting the retail giant to completely overhaul its business model is a bit much, and it is the kind of expectation that leaves a bad taste in our mouth, especially when it comes from a paper that sees AY as a looming catastrophe for Downtown Brooklyn.
With Wal-Mart joining the Brookln Chamber of Commerce and the borough's anti-development voice joining the company's amen chorus it certainly invites the kind of speculation that there are less laudatory selfish interests at work in this entire situation. Can the "booty capitalists" be far behind?
If you read the editorial, however, an interesting pattern emerges. The BPs thinks that a Walmonster in Brooklyn would be different from any other store in the chain. In the first place, "Wal-Mart's standard one-level big box store with an endless parking lot won't fit in Downtown."
What about the company's abysmal labor practices? Not to worry says Brooklyn's authentic voice. "This is not Oskaloosa, Iowa; In Brooklyn, Wal-Mart would not find qualified staff willing to work for sub-par wages and sub-par benefits...Brooklyn presents Wal-Mart with the prefect opportunity to face its critics head on by paying fair wages and offering fair benefits."
Oh, so now we get it. Wal-Mart would be a great addition to Downtown Brooklyn if it just transforms itself into something that it isn't-a transit dependent good employer. As Warner Wolf would say, "Give Me a Break!"
And how about the paper's assumption that, "A Wal-Mart drawing shoppers to Downtown could well enhance the profitability of many nearby businesses..." (unlike if it were built on the periphery). Well there's always a first for everything, and this store becoming a business magnet for others when its entire model is based on eliminating competitors, would break new ground.
So what we end up with is the Brooklyn Papers' offering the borough a classic "pig in a poke." Expecting the retail giant to completely overhaul its business model is a bit much, and it is the kind of expectation that leaves a bad taste in our mouth, especially when it comes from a paper that sees AY as a looming catastrophe for Downtown Brooklyn.
With Wal-Mart joining the Brookln Chamber of Commerce and the borough's anti-development voice joining the company's amen chorus it certainly invites the kind of speculation that there are less laudatory selfish interests at work in this entire situation. Can the "booty capitalists" be far behind?
Friday, July 07, 2006
Cautionary Tale for Wal-Mart in Monsey
With consultants for the proposed Wal-Mart super center doing their evaluation of the store's impact, opponents are gearing up to challenge the "findings" and generate the kind of grass roots opposition that Ramapo electeds will find hard to ignore. Aside from the Alliance and its allies a group from Monsey (not yet identified) has hired attorney Dennis Lynch to represent them in the land use process. Our suspicion is that the group is not any rag-tag outfit if they've come up with Lynch's retainer.
In any case the Alliance's consultant, Brian Ketcham, has outlined a series of issues that the Wal-Mart experts will need to address. The most serious it appears to us involves parking. As we have said before the current parking variance request is for the reduction of the number of spaces needed for the store. As Ketcham says, "If Wal-Mart fails to provide sufficient parking, shoppers will spill over onto Route 59 and into nearby residential communities."
In addition, as per usual in these kinds of developments, the consultants are only looking at a three mile radius from the proposed site. As Ketcham points out, "Wal-Mart will draw from at least a 10 mile radius and must use a study area 10 miles in radius."
Finally, the key issue of socio-economic impact will be a crucial variable because of the slew of minority and Orthodox-owned businesses in the trade area. Lynch tells us that his group will be retaining an expert to evaluate this important issue, and the Alliance may also collaborate in this regard. We're curious to see how the Walmonster's consultants will handle this delicate concern.
In any case we will be meeting with local merchants next Wednesday evening in Monsey. The organizing drive among retailers is going well- no one is happy about the development or sanguine about its salutary impact. Stay tuned for time and place.
In any case the Alliance's consultant, Brian Ketcham, has outlined a series of issues that the Wal-Mart experts will need to address. The most serious it appears to us involves parking. As we have said before the current parking variance request is for the reduction of the number of spaces needed for the store. As Ketcham says, "If Wal-Mart fails to provide sufficient parking, shoppers will spill over onto Route 59 and into nearby residential communities."
In addition, as per usual in these kinds of developments, the consultants are only looking at a three mile radius from the proposed site. As Ketcham points out, "Wal-Mart will draw from at least a 10 mile radius and must use a study area 10 miles in radius."
Finally, the key issue of socio-economic impact will be a crucial variable because of the slew of minority and Orthodox-owned businesses in the trade area. Lynch tells us that his group will be retaining an expert to evaluate this important issue, and the Alliance may also collaborate in this regard. We're curious to see how the Walmonster's consultants will handle this delicate concern.
In any case we will be meeting with local merchants next Wednesday evening in Monsey. The organizing drive among retailers is going well- no one is happy about the development or sanguine about its salutary impact. Stay tuned for time and place.
Thursday, July 06, 2006
Big Mac Attack: Health Corps Expands
As the NY Daily News reports this morning, "Zoning out fast food restaurants isn't the only way to foster healthier eating habits among city youngsters." The other "hearts and minds" approach is the innovative Health Corps initiative that was founded by Dr. Mehmet Oz and is being expanded by Councilman Joel Rivera into three new high schools this fall.
The Health Corps is designed to generate a health activism in the high schools that, if properly activated, will generate greater awareness of healthy living among the friends, families, and in the communities of the Health Corps members. The HC in each school is led by a post grad pre-med volunteer who will organize nutrition workshops, exercise activities and diet awareness programs for the students.
The three schools targeted in the fall will have the HC funded by a city-state grant of $250,000. It is anticipated that the program, which is being monitored for effectiveness by private funding, will be able to further expand at the beginning of the 2007 school year. Quite a few council members have expressed an interest in having HC come to high schools in their districts.
So, for all of the withering criticism that Rivera has received for his "McZoning" proposal, it is clear that the councilman has some substantive plans to go after the change in attitudes that all of his critics say is preferable to zoning out fast-food outlets. It may, however, not be as much of a zero-sum game as many of these critics would like us to believe.
It is time for the fast food folks to become stakeholders in the campaign for healthy eating. If they don't they will find themselves in the same position as Phillip Morris-paying out billions to tell people just how bad smoking really is.
Update: Here are article from El Diario and the Amsterdam News on Councilman Rivera's zoning proposal
The Health Corps is designed to generate a health activism in the high schools that, if properly activated, will generate greater awareness of healthy living among the friends, families, and in the communities of the Health Corps members. The HC in each school is led by a post grad pre-med volunteer who will organize nutrition workshops, exercise activities and diet awareness programs for the students.
The three schools targeted in the fall will have the HC funded by a city-state grant of $250,000. It is anticipated that the program, which is being monitored for effectiveness by private funding, will be able to further expand at the beginning of the 2007 school year. Quite a few council members have expressed an interest in having HC come to high schools in their districts.
So, for all of the withering criticism that Rivera has received for his "McZoning" proposal, it is clear that the councilman has some substantive plans to go after the change in attitudes that all of his critics say is preferable to zoning out fast-food outlets. It may, however, not be as much of a zero-sum game as many of these critics would like us to believe.
It is time for the fast food folks to become stakeholders in the campaign for healthy eating. If they don't they will find themselves in the same position as Phillip Morris-paying out billions to tell people just how bad smoking really is.
Update: Here are article from El Diario and the Amsterdam News on Councilman Rivera's zoning proposal
Wednesday, July 05, 2006
Caveat Vendor
The NY Daily News finally got around to last week's vendor protest at City Hall. A couple of interesting points were made. First, the fact that there are 9,000 "personal licenses" but only 3,000 pushcart permits. According to the paper this means that "some 6,000 are selling without the required pushcart licenses..."
Well, not quite. You see there are many vendors with "personal licenses" who are working for someone who does have a pushcart license and the great likelihood is that a large number of licensed vendors are working as indentured servants for the owner of the pushcart. Not much romance in that story of possible exploitation.
In addition, the paper quotes some"community organizer" who says that the spike in fines and cart confiscation is related to "recent anti-immigrant, anti-minority hate that's been brewing." In Bloomberg's New York? What about in response to illegality?
It seems that these folks aren't content to call for the suspension of all immigration law, they also want to be given carte blanche to hawk their wares anywhere in the city-pedestrian safety and local store owners be damned. This is the sentiment behind the bill to "eliminate a city-imposed limit on the number of vendors issued licenses to sell goods."
Neighborhood store owners are the backbone of this city's economy. They deserve to be protected from freeloading predators who don't support the tax base. This is the battle ahead.
Well, not quite. You see there are many vendors with "personal licenses" who are working for someone who does have a pushcart license and the great likelihood is that a large number of licensed vendors are working as indentured servants for the owner of the pushcart. Not much romance in that story of possible exploitation.
In addition, the paper quotes some"community organizer" who says that the spike in fines and cart confiscation is related to "recent anti-immigrant, anti-minority hate that's been brewing." In Bloomberg's New York? What about in response to illegality?
It seems that these folks aren't content to call for the suspension of all immigration law, they also want to be given carte blanche to hawk their wares anywhere in the city-pedestrian safety and local store owners be damned. This is the sentiment behind the bill to "eliminate a city-imposed limit on the number of vendors issued licenses to sell goods."
Neighborhood store owners are the backbone of this city's economy. They deserve to be protected from freeloading predators who don't support the tax base. This is the battle ahead.
NY Post: Super Anti-Nanny
It took a little longer than we anticipated but the NY Post has finally gotten around to criticizing Joel Rivera's suggestion that the city should use zoning to curb the proliferation of fast food outlets. The paper accuses Rivera of thinking that New Yorkers are all dumb; "Poor people in particular, in his view, are in need of wisdom-because they're not only fat, they're stupid."
The Post feels that everyone is the master of their own fate and deserves to be able to live without the unencumbering control of an intrusive government. Here! Here! All of which overlooks the intrusiveness, not of government, but of an industry that not only seeps into every nook and cranny of everyday life but also wants to seemingly occupy every square inch of the neighborhood.
The River suggestion isn't about control per se, but about the legitimate right of government to use on of its basic police powers to protect the health and welfare of its citizens. Its not the God-given right of the fast fooders to be able to saturate neighborhood commerce and push out the local businesses with their Wall Street driven resources. Which is exactly what other cities and towns all over the country are trying to prevent.
Finally, the Post claims that Rivera, in his zoning obsession, notably overlooks "education, diet, exercise and self-control." Just isn't true. As we have pointed out, the Rivera-sponsored Health Corps initiative in three high schools this fall will do just that. Create a cadre of health activists who will preach the Post's anti-obesity mantra to their friends, families and community, something everyone should support.
The Post feels that everyone is the master of their own fate and deserves to be able to live without the unencumbering control of an intrusive government. Here! Here! All of which overlooks the intrusiveness, not of government, but of an industry that not only seeps into every nook and cranny of everyday life but also wants to seemingly occupy every square inch of the neighborhood.
The River suggestion isn't about control per se, but about the legitimate right of government to use on of its basic police powers to protect the health and welfare of its citizens. Its not the God-given right of the fast fooders to be able to saturate neighborhood commerce and push out the local businesses with their Wall Street driven resources. Which is exactly what other cities and towns all over the country are trying to prevent.
Finally, the Post claims that Rivera, in his zoning obsession, notably overlooks "education, diet, exercise and self-control." Just isn't true. As we have pointed out, the Rivera-sponsored Health Corps initiative in three high schools this fall will do just that. Create a cadre of health activists who will preach the Post's anti-obesity mantra to their friends, families and community, something everyone should support.
More Fast Food Furor
In yesterday's NY Daily News columnist Errol Louis commented about the correlation between obesity and fast food. His "girth of a nation" commentary focuses on a counterattack launched by fast food industry reps against the folks, such as Eric Schlosser of "Fast Food Nation" fame, who have singled them out as prime obesity epidemic suspects.
It turns out that Schlosser is quite the threat since 19 various fast food organizations have started a PR blitz just to "counter the efforts of Eric Schlosser..." We're definitely jealous but the larger point remains: fast food does play a role in the entire obesity crisis and the industry isn't going to escape being targeted by simply spinning tales of fat foods' role in generating good health.
EL also highlights Schlosser's new book, "Chew on This." What the author is pointing out in all of his work is the sheer inescapability of fast food, from the 20,000 junk food ads a year that the average child watches, to the 19,000 schools across the country that sell the stuff in the cafeteria.
The industry response? Why, of course, set up a web set with the beacon of honesty title bestfoodnation.com. Its message? "Obesity is a complex and serious problem that is best addressed by living a balanced lifestyle, making good nutritional choices and getting plenty of exercise." Whenever someone attacked uses the word "complex" it usually means that their trying to say that the problem under scrutiny is really not their fault.
As we have said before, however, the industry is part of the problem. If "making good nutritional choices" is a key variable here than the industry can't sit back and let others take the lead. It needs to devote some of its considerable resources to the solution and not to defensive hectoring.
It turns out that Schlosser is quite the threat since 19 various fast food organizations have started a PR blitz just to "counter the efforts of Eric Schlosser..." We're definitely jealous but the larger point remains: fast food does play a role in the entire obesity crisis and the industry isn't going to escape being targeted by simply spinning tales of fat foods' role in generating good health.
EL also highlights Schlosser's new book, "Chew on This." What the author is pointing out in all of his work is the sheer inescapability of fast food, from the 20,000 junk food ads a year that the average child watches, to the 19,000 schools across the country that sell the stuff in the cafeteria.
The industry response? Why, of course, set up a web set with the beacon of honesty title bestfoodnation.com. Its message? "Obesity is a complex and serious problem that is best addressed by living a balanced lifestyle, making good nutritional choices and getting plenty of exercise." Whenever someone attacked uses the word "complex" it usually means that their trying to say that the problem under scrutiny is really not their fault.
As we have said before, however, the industry is part of the problem. If "making good nutritional choices" is a key variable here than the industry can't sit back and let others take the lead. It needs to devote some of its considerable resources to the solution and not to defensive hectoring.
Monday, July 03, 2006
Stinging Up the Wrong Tree
Last week the NY Sun reported on the results of a city investigation into the selling of cigarettes to minors. Nearly 200 bodegas and supermarkets were caught in the investigation. Mayor Bloomberg, commenting on the city's action said, "These businesses are all too willing to put cigarettes in the hands of our kids."
The mayor, with his confiscatory cigarette tax-one that he's looking to increase by 50 cents-is all too willing to put cigarettes in the hands of black marketers who are selling these illegal smokes on the streets of New York. Guess what? No one from the city's DCA is citing these criminals for their illegal behavior.
It's always the legitimate store owners who are targeted. Of course no one examines the ethics of some of these sting operations. As an employee of Space Market, a store that had its license revoked, on University Place told the Sun, "They sent people who looked like they were thirty, at least 28, and they were underage..."
Mayor Bloomberg needs to step up and take a strong stand against the black market activity that is taking over the city's streets. Between the cigarette hawkers and the fruit peddlers the rights of store owners don't appear to concern this administration too much.
The mayor, with his confiscatory cigarette tax-one that he's looking to increase by 50 cents-is all too willing to put cigarettes in the hands of black marketers who are selling these illegal smokes on the streets of New York. Guess what? No one from the city's DCA is citing these criminals for their illegal behavior.
It's always the legitimate store owners who are targeted. Of course no one examines the ethics of some of these sting operations. As an employee of Space Market, a store that had its license revoked, on University Place told the Sun, "They sent people who looked like they were thirty, at least 28, and they were underage..."
Mayor Bloomberg needs to step up and take a strong stand against the black market activity that is taking over the city's streets. Between the cigarette hawkers and the fruit peddlers the rights of store owners don't appear to concern this administration too much.
Friday, June 30, 2006
Fast Food Redux
On a related issue to our last post it is important to point out that Andrew Wolf's critique of Rivera's efforts to use the zoning tool to curb fast food outlets is, on this issue, just factually inaccurate. He argues that the councilman's proposal "will not be the first time that zoning regulations will be misused to advance an unrelated non-land use decision" (He refers to the Alliance's successful effort to stop a BJ's from being built on Brush Avenue).
The fact say otherwise. As we have pointed out, there is no stronger zoning rationale than the protection of the public's health and safety. In fact, the 1916 NYC comprehensive zoning law, the first of its kind in the nation, rested squarely on the correlation between the municipalities police power to regulate public health.
Now you might not believe that there is a correlation between obesity and fast food (as we're sure Wolf does not) but if a strong link can be established, as it has been in recent research in public health, that there is no stronger rationale for zoning than that.
The fact say otherwise. As we have pointed out, there is no stronger zoning rationale than the protection of the public's health and safety. In fact, the 1916 NYC comprehensive zoning law, the first of its kind in the nation, rested squarely on the correlation between the municipalities police power to regulate public health.
Now you might not believe that there is a correlation between obesity and fast food (as we're sure Wolf does not) but if a strong link can be established, as it has been in recent research in public health, that there is no stronger rationale for zoning than that.
Wolfing Down the Fast Food
In today's NY Sun columnist Andrew Wolf continues his attack on the those who believe that we need to do something drastic about what our kids eat. Initially he had ridiculed the efforts of former president Clinton to eliminate soft drinks from our schools, and now he takes aim at Joel Rivera's proposal to use zoning as a tool to restrict the number of neighborhood fast food outlets.
What's interesting in the Wolf piece is his skepticism about the entire issue of childhood obesity. As he says about the Rivera proposal, "This seems to be strong medicine for a disease that I'm not sure really exists. There is precious little evidence of any long term health danger posed by this 'epidemic' either to children or to adults."
Wolf opines that although Americans are getting fatter they are still living longer. "Nor is there any evidence that attempts to manipulate portions of the diets of children will really result in weight loss." This is all very provocative but also useful, because what Wolf is arguing is subject to rigorous scientific evaluation.
He also argues that all of this diet restriction "hysteria" will have harmful repercussions, "but it won't be a glut of fat children. Rather we will see an epidemic of eating disorders, similar to what we have seen among young women in recent years."
The reason? It's because we are supposedly taking a pleasurable activity and investing it with "anxiety and alarm." Here Wolf's argument devolves into the hysteria that he criticizes in others. Not only that he has created the "restrictive diet" strawman that is not central to the thrust of the anti obesity effort aimed at children.
Wolf cites the author of a book called "The Tyranny of Health" who critiques the efforts to "coerce children into a 'five a day' fruit and vegetable consumption..." that will rob our children of the "sensual enjoyment of eating and drinking." This is not what the opponents of fast food and its corresponding gluttony have in mind in their efforts to fight the growing obesity problem.
In questioning the existence of an obesity epidemic Wolf reminds us of the Marx Brothers' line: "Who are you going to believe, me or your own lying eyes?" But give Wolf credit for bringing this to the fore and now that he has done so we would suggest that Councilman Rivera, along with his collaborator on the Health Corps, Dr. Mehmet Oz of Columbia-Presbyterian, convene a conference in the Fall that addresses all of the various points of view on the subject.
What's interesting in the Wolf piece is his skepticism about the entire issue of childhood obesity. As he says about the Rivera proposal, "This seems to be strong medicine for a disease that I'm not sure really exists. There is precious little evidence of any long term health danger posed by this 'epidemic' either to children or to adults."
Wolf opines that although Americans are getting fatter they are still living longer. "Nor is there any evidence that attempts to manipulate portions of the diets of children will really result in weight loss." This is all very provocative but also useful, because what Wolf is arguing is subject to rigorous scientific evaluation.
He also argues that all of this diet restriction "hysteria" will have harmful repercussions, "but it won't be a glut of fat children. Rather we will see an epidemic of eating disorders, similar to what we have seen among young women in recent years."
The reason? It's because we are supposedly taking a pleasurable activity and investing it with "anxiety and alarm." Here Wolf's argument devolves into the hysteria that he criticizes in others. Not only that he has created the "restrictive diet" strawman that is not central to the thrust of the anti obesity effort aimed at children.
Wolf cites the author of a book called "The Tyranny of Health" who critiques the efforts to "coerce children into a 'five a day' fruit and vegetable consumption..." that will rob our children of the "sensual enjoyment of eating and drinking." This is not what the opponents of fast food and its corresponding gluttony have in mind in their efforts to fight the growing obesity problem.
In questioning the existence of an obesity epidemic Wolf reminds us of the Marx Brothers' line: "Who are you going to believe, me or your own lying eyes?" But give Wolf credit for bringing this to the fore and now that he has done so we would suggest that Councilman Rivera, along with his collaborator on the Health Corps, Dr. Mehmet Oz of Columbia-Presbyterian, convene a conference in the Fall that addresses all of the various points of view on the subject.
Whose Community?
Hats off to the Riverdale Review (and to our friends at Save Our Parks for calling attention to the piece), for its commentary about the actions of BP Carrion in regards to the galling nerve of CB #4 to actually attempt to represent the community's interest. As we have said before, Carrion has done us all a public service by disabusing us of the idea that these boards are actually in place to live up to their name.
All kidding aside, the sacking of the board raises a number of serious issues that relate to the integrity of the ULURP process. Also being questioned here is the competency of Carrion to be a mayoral candidate in 2009. As the Review said, "If Carrion cannot deal with a little difference of opinion over one issue in the Bronx, how could he ever govern an entire city with eight million points of view?
All kidding aside, the sacking of the board raises a number of serious issues that relate to the integrity of the ULURP process. Also being questioned here is the competency of Carrion to be a mayoral candidate in 2009. As the Review said, "If Carrion cannot deal with a little difference of opinion over one issue in the Bronx, how could he ever govern an entire city with eight million points of view?
Pushcart Before the Horse
As the NY Post reports today there was a protest yesterday in front of City Hall by unlicensed street vendors who are complaining about their carts being "wheeled away by the city for lack of proper licensing." A group called Street Vendors for Justice is protesting the move complaining that about 20 carts have been, along with the goods they contained, confiscated by the city.
NY1 picks up the story and quotes one of the unlicensed (undocumented?) vendors saying, "We are asking for an unlimited amount of licenses," and Councilman Charles Barron seems to agree since he has introduced a bill to raise the 3,000 license cap. As the Councilman told the Post, "Why should we restrict access to be fully licensed when they are just trying to make an honest living?"
Why should we restrict? Well for one thing these folks who are just trying to make an honest living (By working illegally?) are actually taking business away from the tax paying store owners they often set up their carts right in front of. If they are only interested in feeding their families than they should look for work at one of the countless supermarkets that are constantly looking for new employees.
If they are afraid to actually apply for a real documented job than we do have a real problem with illegal immigrants coming into the city and threatening, through their unlicensed peddling, to undermine the city's tax base. Calcutta hear we come!
One last point. The Post points out that the city only licenses 3,000 pushcarts but, at the same time, licenses 9,000 vendors. What this means is that the city is creating a pool of contract laborers to work for unscrupulous goods wholesalers. The exploitation is inevitable and needs to be investigated.
NY1 picks up the story and quotes one of the unlicensed (undocumented?) vendors saying, "We are asking for an unlimited amount of licenses," and Councilman Charles Barron seems to agree since he has introduced a bill to raise the 3,000 license cap. As the Councilman told the Post, "Why should we restrict access to be fully licensed when they are just trying to make an honest living?"
Why should we restrict? Well for one thing these folks who are just trying to make an honest living (By working illegally?) are actually taking business away from the tax paying store owners they often set up their carts right in front of. If they are only interested in feeding their families than they should look for work at one of the countless supermarkets that are constantly looking for new employees.
If they are afraid to actually apply for a real documented job than we do have a real problem with illegal immigrants coming into the city and threatening, through their unlicensed peddling, to undermine the city's tax base. Calcutta hear we come!
One last point. The Post points out that the city only licenses 3,000 pushcarts but, at the same time, licenses 9,000 vendors. What this means is that the city is creating a pool of contract laborers to work for unscrupulous goods wholesalers. The exploitation is inevitable and needs to be investigated.
Thursday, June 29, 2006
Rivera Post Toasted
In today's letter section of the NY Post the paper's readers take aim against Councilman Rivera's suggestion that we use zoning laws to curb the proliferation of fast food outlets. The thrust of the opposition view is expressed by Nat Weiner of the Bronx who suggests that Joel Rivera "attack the root causes of obesity."
Well Nat, Rivera must be listening to you because included in the just concluded budget deal is an initial $250,000 Rivera-sponsored grant to expand the Health Corps program to three additional high schools in the fall. The Health Corps goal is to change the attitudes of young people aboujt health and nutrition. So, while we partially agree with letter writer Karen Parisi of Maryland that, "it is not the government's job to control what our children eat," we also believe that government can and should play an educational role in this area.
Well Nat, Rivera must be listening to you because included in the just concluded budget deal is an initial $250,000 Rivera-sponsored grant to expand the Health Corps program to three additional high schools in the fall. The Health Corps goal is to change the attitudes of young people aboujt health and nutrition. So, while we partially agree with letter writer Karen Parisi of Maryland that, "it is not the government's job to control what our children eat," we also believe that government can and should play an educational role in this area.
Environmental Hypocrisy
The NY Times has a great story in today's paper about rats "swaggering" in East Harlem. Swagger they do because the latest city effort to curb their population hasn't really made a dent into the profusion of their numbers. An audit released last week by Comptroller Thompson found that the city's response to rat complaints "was slow" even though DOH has improved somewhat in its fight against the rodents.
All of which underscores what we have been saying all along about the need to go after the source of rat nourishment, the food waste that attracts them in the first place. This can be significantly accomplished through a program to install both commercial and residential food waste disposers. It is exactly why the NYCHA has installed disposers in housing projects on the Lower East Side and Bushwick.
Instead, precisely because of the misguided effort of some of the city's leading environmental groups Intro 133, a measure that would eliminate the rat food source, remains stalled. Stalled because groups such as the NRDC are more concerned about the algae in the Jamaica Bay than they are about the poor folks of East Harlem.
A concern for public health was the primary reason for the City of Philadelphia to mandate the use of food waste disposers for any store and restaurant that applied for a dumpster permit. The solid waste benefits of disposers are clear, but when we add the positive impact that their use will have on neighborhood public health it is inexplicable that the City Council has not seen fit to act on legislation that is sponsored by 36 members.
All of which underscores what we have been saying all along about the need to go after the source of rat nourishment, the food waste that attracts them in the first place. This can be significantly accomplished through a program to install both commercial and residential food waste disposers. It is exactly why the NYCHA has installed disposers in housing projects on the Lower East Side and Bushwick.
Instead, precisely because of the misguided effort of some of the city's leading environmental groups Intro 133, a measure that would eliminate the rat food source, remains stalled. Stalled because groups such as the NRDC are more concerned about the algae in the Jamaica Bay than they are about the poor folks of East Harlem.
A concern for public health was the primary reason for the City of Philadelphia to mandate the use of food waste disposers for any store and restaurant that applied for a dumpster permit. The solid waste benefits of disposers are clear, but when we add the positive impact that their use will have on neighborhood public health it is inexplicable that the City Council has not seen fit to act on legislation that is sponsored by 36 members.
Wednesday, June 28, 2006
Crain's Gives Us Props
We need to give a shout out to the Crain's Insider for singling this blog out in this morning's In$ider. The kind words-"an informative pro-union blog"-were appreciated and, hopefully, the observation that our observations "rarely generate comments" can be seen as a result of our emphasis on policy analysis rather than pure partisan rabble rousing.
We do have a point-of-view but our pro union stance is usually restricted to the box store issue, since our main focus is on defending neighborhood stores. Our goal is definitely to advance certain issues but we like to inform as many as possible on the various sides of any policy debate. Sometimes this wish is limited, as some readers never fail to point out, by the fact that we are in business to defend our clients' interests.
We do have a point-of-view but our pro union stance is usually restricted to the box store issue, since our main focus is on defending neighborhood stores. Our goal is definitely to advance certain issues but we like to inform as many as possible on the various sides of any policy debate. Sometimes this wish is limited, as some readers never fail to point out, by the fact that we are in business to defend our clients' interests.
Journal News Says No!- to Wal-Mart in Monsey
In today's Rockland Journal News the paper editorializes against the building of a Wal-Mart supercenter in Monsey, N.Y. In doing so the paper praises the Town of Ramapo for scoring "a win for planning common sense by requiring that the developer...provide a study of its economic ramifications." This precisely what the Alliance had been urging the planners to do and the the Board's chair, Sylvain Klein, properly made sure that the study was included.
The JN feels that the economic impact analysis could (should?) "highlight the good reasons why there should not be a super center or other major developments in the congested Monsey corridor." The paper feels that the project could "hinder renewal and force store closings" in Spring Valley and along Rt. 59 in Monsey.
One key point that the Journal adds is the need for the Ramapo planners to look at the report "with healthy skepticism." Which is precisely why the Alliance, much as it has done in NYC in its BJs and Wal-Mart fights, plans to do its own impact analysis in conjunction with both the Ramapo Jewish Chamber of Commerce and the Spring Valley Chamber. Ramapo simply cannot rely on the self serving data provided by National Realty and Development Corp.
Finally, the JN tells the Ramapo planners to"have the courage of your convictions" and be prepared to "say 'No' to whatever you must in the interest of the people." One important point is left out here, however. The one man who holds the fate of this project in his hand is Ramapo supervisor St. Lawrence and we've been hearing that he may not have the same degree of healthy skepticism toward Wal-Mart that the JN has.
If true, you can depend that he will be hearing from the good folks in Monsey and Spring Valley. If he listens to the voice of the people than there is a good chance that the Wal-Mart project won't "damn the St. Lawrence."
The JN feels that the economic impact analysis could (should?) "highlight the good reasons why there should not be a super center or other major developments in the congested Monsey corridor." The paper feels that the project could "hinder renewal and force store closings" in Spring Valley and along Rt. 59 in Monsey.
One key point that the Journal adds is the need for the Ramapo planners to look at the report "with healthy skepticism." Which is precisely why the Alliance, much as it has done in NYC in its BJs and Wal-Mart fights, plans to do its own impact analysis in conjunction with both the Ramapo Jewish Chamber of Commerce and the Spring Valley Chamber. Ramapo simply cannot rely on the self serving data provided by National Realty and Development Corp.
Finally, the JN tells the Ramapo planners to"have the courage of your convictions" and be prepared to "say 'No' to whatever you must in the interest of the people." One important point is left out here, however. The one man who holds the fate of this project in his hand is Ramapo supervisor St. Lawrence and we've been hearing that he may not have the same degree of healthy skepticism toward Wal-Mart that the JN has.
If true, you can depend that he will be hearing from the good folks in Monsey and Spring Valley. If he listens to the voice of the people than there is a good chance that the Wal-Mart project won't "damn the St. Lawrence."
Tuesday, June 27, 2006
Garbage Deja Vu
Yesterday's City Council hearing on the city's SWMP took a very predictable course. As the NY Times points out, opponents of Manhattan transfer stations came out to inveigh against the siting of facilities on 91st Street and 14th Street. In turn, proponents of the mayor's plan accused the protestors of being insensitive to the fact that minority communities have had to put up with these stations for years.
As we have been saying all along, this is all an exquisite result of two things: the mayor's clever emphasis on "environmental justice," and the plan's failure to address any substantive proposal for waste reduction. The result is the current fight over a couple of transfer stations, and the total disavowal of the need to come up with a cost-effective waste reduction and disposal plan.
This is all kind of a Kabuki theater presentation as lawmakers debate issues that are only partially germane to dealing with the need for a less expensive and more comprehensive garbage solution. And, as David Yassky tells the Crain's In$ider this morning, "he won't vote for the plan because he believes that the Sanitation Department has not fully developed the commercial part of it."
Crain's goes on to point out that "commercial trash haulers have been lobbying against the mayor's proposal." This is because the city is looking to channel all of the commercial waste into a city-controlled 59th Street transfer station. Something that the NY Times has approved of without giving much thought to its feasibility or legality. In addition, the paper exhorts the city to recycle private waste with no clear idea just how this is supposed to get done.
All of which gets us to the essence of Intro 133. This proposal to experiment with the feasibility of legalizing commercial food waste disposers would demonstrate the dramatic potential to reduce the export of commercial waste by over 90%. Once the numbers are crunched we strongly believe that the necessity of building an expensive commercial waste station at 59th Street would be obviated. Not to mention the potential to address the public health issue that is created by the city's rat epidemic.
It will be interesting to see whether council people like Yassky, Monseratte, Garodnick, Lappin and Rivera can push the body in a positive public health and solid waste direction. If they do the current plan can have the number of transfer stations, and the amount of overall garbage exports, reduced in all neighborhoods.
As we have been saying all along, this is all an exquisite result of two things: the mayor's clever emphasis on "environmental justice," and the plan's failure to address any substantive proposal for waste reduction. The result is the current fight over a couple of transfer stations, and the total disavowal of the need to come up with a cost-effective waste reduction and disposal plan.
This is all kind of a Kabuki theater presentation as lawmakers debate issues that are only partially germane to dealing with the need for a less expensive and more comprehensive garbage solution. And, as David Yassky tells the Crain's In$ider this morning, "he won't vote for the plan because he believes that the Sanitation Department has not fully developed the commercial part of it."
Crain's goes on to point out that "commercial trash haulers have been lobbying against the mayor's proposal." This is because the city is looking to channel all of the commercial waste into a city-controlled 59th Street transfer station. Something that the NY Times has approved of without giving much thought to its feasibility or legality. In addition, the paper exhorts the city to recycle private waste with no clear idea just how this is supposed to get done.
All of which gets us to the essence of Intro 133. This proposal to experiment with the feasibility of legalizing commercial food waste disposers would demonstrate the dramatic potential to reduce the export of commercial waste by over 90%. Once the numbers are crunched we strongly believe that the necessity of building an expensive commercial waste station at 59th Street would be obviated. Not to mention the potential to address the public health issue that is created by the city's rat epidemic.
It will be interesting to see whether council people like Yassky, Monseratte, Garodnick, Lappin and Rivera can push the body in a positive public health and solid waste direction. If they do the current plan can have the number of transfer stations, and the amount of overall garbage exports, reduced in all neighborhoods.
Monday, June 26, 2006
McZoning: Fat Chance?
In today's NY Post the paper picks up on the fact that, "The City Council's push for a McZoning law to restrict the number of fast-food restaurants is not so far-fetched-a study conducted by Bloomberg's alma mater strongly endorsed such a crackdown." The Post also reports, as we have commented, on the fact that other municipalities have enacted restrictions on fast food outlets, including Detroit, where no fast food place is allowed within 500 feet of a school.
All of which is to once again point out that the obesity issue isn't something that should be a subject of ridicule. The problem is so serious that a National Obesity Action Forum has been established and in its meeting earlier this month the group began strategizing how to further reduce obesity. As the Journal News reports this morning, "A Food and Drug Administration-funded report released this month assesses the annual medical cost of the overweight problem at nearly $93 billion."
The crisis in poor Black and Latino communities is so severe that the clergy in Harlem has become activated to combat the epidemic. Led by Dr. Olajide Williams, a member of the Central Harlem Obesity Workshop, a "Health Revival" plan has been launched by Harlem ministers "to attack obesity among the super-sized in their pews."
Zoning-out fast food outlets, as Elizabeth Whelan opines in today's NY Sun, may not be the best strategy to combat the obesity epidemic but its threat may be necessary to energize an industry that the Journal News tells us "is balking at proposals to require sharing detailed nutrition information with customers..." They respond to the suggestion by claiming that "it is not food establishments' role to police what people eat."
The first recognition that tobacco was a danger to public health surfaced in 1920. It took us over 85 years to reach where we are on this subject today. With obesity we simply don't have that much time to get a serious grip on the problem. We need immediate drastic action today, and the fears of Big Government that Whelan expresses are not as frightening as the proliferation of preventable chronic diseases that are directly attributable to obesity.
All of which is to once again point out that the obesity issue isn't something that should be a subject of ridicule. The problem is so serious that a National Obesity Action Forum has been established and in its meeting earlier this month the group began strategizing how to further reduce obesity. As the Journal News reports this morning, "A Food and Drug Administration-funded report released this month assesses the annual medical cost of the overweight problem at nearly $93 billion."
The crisis in poor Black and Latino communities is so severe that the clergy in Harlem has become activated to combat the epidemic. Led by Dr. Olajide Williams, a member of the Central Harlem Obesity Workshop, a "Health Revival" plan has been launched by Harlem ministers "to attack obesity among the super-sized in their pews."
Zoning-out fast food outlets, as Elizabeth Whelan opines in today's NY Sun, may not be the best strategy to combat the obesity epidemic but its threat may be necessary to energize an industry that the Journal News tells us "is balking at proposals to require sharing detailed nutrition information with customers..." They respond to the suggestion by claiming that "it is not food establishments' role to police what people eat."
The first recognition that tobacco was a danger to public health surfaced in 1920. It took us over 85 years to reach where we are on this subject today. With obesity we simply don't have that much time to get a serious grip on the problem. We need immediate drastic action today, and the fears of Big Government that Whelan expresses are not as frightening as the proliferation of preventable chronic diseases that are directly attributable to obesity.
Solid Waste Movement
The NY Times editorialized yesterday on the need for the City Council to adopt the mayor's SWMP with little or no tinkering: "Because the plan's placement of transfer sites hangs like a Caldor mobile, the City Council should adopt it without too much tampering."
What's troubling about the paper's view is its lack of emphasis on just how the city is going to "expand recycling to businesses," something that the Times thinks needs to be done. As it points out, "Ultimately the task of successfully managing trash will require not just burial or incineration, but reuse and reduction of rubbish as well."
Just so. However, isn't it incumbent of a solid waste plan to actually lay out some coherent methodology for waste reduction? This is totally missing in the city's elaborate siting plan. The sections on recycling are devoid of any useful proposal that would make anyone but the mayor's most ardent acolytes sanguine about the possibility of waste reduction.
And what about the 59th Street commercial waste transfer station?- something the Times tells us is "without question necessary for Manhattan, which produces 40 percent of business trash." The paper doesn't say just how the city is going to incentivize or, perhaps, force the private carters to divert waste to that transfer point from others that they are already using.
All of this is, of course, frustrating to us because of the myopia that exists around the one methodology, the installation of commercial food waste disposers, that could "expand recycling to businesses" and reduce rubbish as well. This is particularly true of Manhattan where food waste is a significant component of the commercial waste stream.
Without any real waste reduction strategy the city moves ineluctably towards a fiscal and solid waste nightmare. The Times, unfortunately, neglects to raise any questions about the escalating costs of disposal, costs that are exacerbated by reliance on questionable export-landfill destinations as well as on the failure of the city to reduce the amount of waste being transported.
What's troubling about the paper's view is its lack of emphasis on just how the city is going to "expand recycling to businesses," something that the Times thinks needs to be done. As it points out, "Ultimately the task of successfully managing trash will require not just burial or incineration, but reuse and reduction of rubbish as well."
Just so. However, isn't it incumbent of a solid waste plan to actually lay out some coherent methodology for waste reduction? This is totally missing in the city's elaborate siting plan. The sections on recycling are devoid of any useful proposal that would make anyone but the mayor's most ardent acolytes sanguine about the possibility of waste reduction.
And what about the 59th Street commercial waste transfer station?- something the Times tells us is "without question necessary for Manhattan, which produces 40 percent of business trash." The paper doesn't say just how the city is going to incentivize or, perhaps, force the private carters to divert waste to that transfer point from others that they are already using.
All of this is, of course, frustrating to us because of the myopia that exists around the one methodology, the installation of commercial food waste disposers, that could "expand recycling to businesses" and reduce rubbish as well. This is particularly true of Manhattan where food waste is a significant component of the commercial waste stream.
Without any real waste reduction strategy the city moves ineluctably towards a fiscal and solid waste nightmare. The Times, unfortunately, neglects to raise any questions about the escalating costs of disposal, costs that are exacerbated by reliance on questionable export-landfill destinations as well as on the failure of the city to reduce the amount of waste being transported.
Will Power, Fast Food and "Common Sense"
The crescendo of ridicule that was generated by Councilman Joel Rivera's trial balloon about using the city's zoning laws to reduce the availability of fast food joints continues. This time it is the acid-tongued Ellis Henican in Friday's Newsday. In what must be considered unintentional irony, the liberal Henican morphed into Nancy Reagen with his injunction to, "Just say no to the jumbo fries."
Henican does ask a series of legitimate questions regarding the overall legality of the proposal and the definition of what exactly qualifies as fast food. He than also points out that there are a whole host of things that government can do-like "smart nutritional education" and "not canceling the phys ed classes in school"-but goes on to pose the following question: "does anyone really believe the answer lies in making colonel Sanders move down the street?
Well, a lot of public health researchers think that zoning is part of a comprehensive approach to the serious public health crisis generated by this country's obesity epidemic. In fact they point out that the most fundamental underpinning of all zoning regulations is public health and safety. Not only that, a great many municipalities have already taken zoning action against fast food, although not for obesity per se, and these ordinances have survived legal challenge.
It doesn't mean that a number of Henican's other suggestions shouldn't also be included in any anti-obesity health policy. In fact, as we have pointed out, Rivera is doing just that in his sponsorship of Dr. Mehmet Oz's Health Corps initiative. Better education should be the main thrust of any policy but the proliferation of fast food establishments, especially in low income areas, is a problem that can be addressed through zoning.
If, as it is in San Francisco, Newport RI, Concord, MA etc, zoning is being invoked against fast food and "formula" restaurants on the grounds of "community character," than it can be used for a legitimate public health purpose in the fight against obesity. It might be a last resort remedy, to be used only in the event that the fast food industry maintains a deaf ear about the obesity epidemic, but it should certainly be examined for its efficacy and be held in abeyance so that the fast fooders know that policy makers are serious.
Henican does ask a series of legitimate questions regarding the overall legality of the proposal and the definition of what exactly qualifies as fast food. He than also points out that there are a whole host of things that government can do-like "smart nutritional education" and "not canceling the phys ed classes in school"-but goes on to pose the following question: "does anyone really believe the answer lies in making colonel Sanders move down the street?
Well, a lot of public health researchers think that zoning is part of a comprehensive approach to the serious public health crisis generated by this country's obesity epidemic. In fact they point out that the most fundamental underpinning of all zoning regulations is public health and safety. Not only that, a great many municipalities have already taken zoning action against fast food, although not for obesity per se, and these ordinances have survived legal challenge.
It doesn't mean that a number of Henican's other suggestions shouldn't also be included in any anti-obesity health policy. In fact, as we have pointed out, Rivera is doing just that in his sponsorship of Dr. Mehmet Oz's Health Corps initiative. Better education should be the main thrust of any policy but the proliferation of fast food establishments, especially in low income areas, is a problem that can be addressed through zoning.
If, as it is in San Francisco, Newport RI, Concord, MA etc, zoning is being invoked against fast food and "formula" restaurants on the grounds of "community character," than it can be used for a legitimate public health purpose in the fight against obesity. It might be a last resort remedy, to be used only in the event that the fast food industry maintains a deaf ear about the obesity epidemic, but it should certainly be examined for its efficacy and be held in abeyance so that the fast fooders know that policy makers are serious.
Friday, June 23, 2006
Daily News Zones Out: From Obesity to Opacity
In today's NY Daily News the paper editorializes against the suggestion, advanced by Health Committee Chair Joel Rivera, that city zoning law be used to control the proliferation of fast food joints in neighborhoods where childhood obesity has reached epidemic proportion. The councilman's proposal earned him a "Knucklehead Award" from the paper's pontificators.
In this case, however the shoe, or should we say the dunce cap, is being worn by the wrong party. In their efforts to belittle the proposal the News' erudite crew resorts to ridicule:"Lose Your Butt Bill," "Slaw and Order candidate," etc. The epidemic of obesity, and its attendant diseases, is no laughing matter. In one estimate 365,000 deaths a year can be attributed to obesity, making the disease second only to tobacco use as a killer in this country.
We can ask the smug editorialists, just what has the Daily News done to be part of the solution for a health crisis that is plaguing the kinds of neighborhoods that are represented by Mr. Rivera? The unfortunate answer is- absolutely nothing. Instead of being proactive and helpful the paper's rhetoric degenerates into sarcasm.
What makes the ridicule even more misplaced is the ignorance that the editorial page exhibits on the entire zoning/obesity questioning. You see, the musings on the subject do not originate from the solitary ruminations of Rivera but, instead, are drawn directly from the cutting edge scientific research being done in public health at-hold onto your seats-The Center for Law and the Public's Health at the John Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
So before we kill the messenger here isn't appropriate to first question all of the highbrow folks that are being partially funded by our own mayor's largesse? When we look at the work being done in the field we find that there are a lot of serious researchers who believe that zoning can be used as a tool to control obesity (See "The Use of Zoning To Restrict Fast Food Outlets: A Potential Strategy to Combat Obesity, October, 2005). Not only that, the mayor's health commissioner certainly hasn't ruled the zoning tool out.
Now the News might not agree with the researchers' conclusions but it needs to become better informed on the subject before the lapse into ridicule makes them look, well, ridiculous. If they review the literature they might discover that the historical foundation for all zoning is the protection of the public's health and safety. Not only that, zoning is already being used in other parts of the country for the purpose that Councilman Rivera suggests.
The obesity epidemic (which costs New York state $3.5 billion just in Medicaid payments) and the concomitant health crisis is probably the most important public health challenge we face in this country. Fast food is not the only contributing factor but it certainly plays its part. The fast food industry needs to wake up and become part of the solution-and so does the Daily News. If this doesn't happen than more punitive measures will be forthcoming. The handwriting is on the wall and you don't have to be a seer to read it.
In this case, however the shoe, or should we say the dunce cap, is being worn by the wrong party. In their efforts to belittle the proposal the News' erudite crew resorts to ridicule:"Lose Your Butt Bill," "Slaw and Order candidate," etc. The epidemic of obesity, and its attendant diseases, is no laughing matter. In one estimate 365,000 deaths a year can be attributed to obesity, making the disease second only to tobacco use as a killer in this country.
We can ask the smug editorialists, just what has the Daily News done to be part of the solution for a health crisis that is plaguing the kinds of neighborhoods that are represented by Mr. Rivera? The unfortunate answer is- absolutely nothing. Instead of being proactive and helpful the paper's rhetoric degenerates into sarcasm.
What makes the ridicule even more misplaced is the ignorance that the editorial page exhibits on the entire zoning/obesity questioning. You see, the musings on the subject do not originate from the solitary ruminations of Rivera but, instead, are drawn directly from the cutting edge scientific research being done in public health at-hold onto your seats-The Center for Law and the Public's Health at the John Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.
So before we kill the messenger here isn't appropriate to first question all of the highbrow folks that are being partially funded by our own mayor's largesse? When we look at the work being done in the field we find that there are a lot of serious researchers who believe that zoning can be used as a tool to control obesity (See "The Use of Zoning To Restrict Fast Food Outlets: A Potential Strategy to Combat Obesity, October, 2005). Not only that, the mayor's health commissioner certainly hasn't ruled the zoning tool out.
Now the News might not agree with the researchers' conclusions but it needs to become better informed on the subject before the lapse into ridicule makes them look, well, ridiculous. If they review the literature they might discover that the historical foundation for all zoning is the protection of the public's health and safety. Not only that, zoning is already being used in other parts of the country for the purpose that Councilman Rivera suggests.
The obesity epidemic (which costs New York state $3.5 billion just in Medicaid payments) and the concomitant health crisis is probably the most important public health challenge we face in this country. Fast food is not the only contributing factor but it certainly plays its part. The fast food industry needs to wake up and become part of the solution-and so does the Daily News. If this doesn't happen than more punitive measures will be forthcoming. The handwriting is on the wall and you don't have to be a seer to read it.
Thursday, June 22, 2006
Zoning for Fast Food?
At yesterday's City Council Health Committee hearing the committee's chair, Councilman Joel Rivera, "proposed overhauling the city's zoning rules to limit the number of fast food restaurants in neighborhoods where obesity is epidemic among youths." Obesity was the subject of the hearing.
The Alliance applauds Rivera's desire to do something about the obesity epidemic. We do, however, think there are better ways to do it that don't involve restrictive zoning changes that may not even be feasible. The Alliance doesn't hold a great deal of sympathy for the fast food chains that have pushed out indigenous neighborhood eateries, but zoning changes could have unintentional consequences and could hurt the growth of neighborhood economies.
In the first place even coming up with a definition of fast food wouldn't be easy. As Mitchell Moss of NYU points out in today's NY Daily News, "it's unlikely any zoning resolution could dictate that level of detail. The zoning code for eating and drinking establishments does not distinguish types of food. "
Testifying yesterday at the hearing, though, was our good friend, Dr. Lynn Silver of the NYC DOH. Silver is in charge of the city's efforts to reduce obesity rates in the city's poorest neighborhoods. The doctor told the committee that "restrictive zoning seemed to be a 'perfect example' of how government could help control the epidemic."
Not so fast. As one Yonkers teacher told the NY Post, "'Trying to hide a donut won't work...,' said Gary Londis...He said teaching kids to exercise and eat better would be more practical." Exactly so. In a city where 21% of kindergarteners are already obese drastic intervention is necessary.
Which brings us to Rivera's major new health initiative: the expansion of Dr. Oz's Health Corps concept. Health Corps, using a Peace Corps-like model, trains volunteers who then are placed in underserved high schools to teach various health-based lessons. The program is already being piloted in two city high schools and is designed to create a grass roots activism for health among the city's young people. Judging from its initial reception, the program could be the beginning of an attitude revolution, one that could lead to the kind of life-style changes that would make any zoning change superfluous.
Assisting in these lifestyle alternations should be the fast food companies that Councilman Rivera cites. It would make perfect sense for the McDonalds of the world to team up with Health Corps to encourage healthy eating and proper exercise. Childhood obesity and diabetes are socially and economically costly and the best way to combat these epidemics is, in partnership with food retailers, to convince young people to make improved choices.
The Alliance applauds Rivera's desire to do something about the obesity epidemic. We do, however, think there are better ways to do it that don't involve restrictive zoning changes that may not even be feasible. The Alliance doesn't hold a great deal of sympathy for the fast food chains that have pushed out indigenous neighborhood eateries, but zoning changes could have unintentional consequences and could hurt the growth of neighborhood economies.
In the first place even coming up with a definition of fast food wouldn't be easy. As Mitchell Moss of NYU points out in today's NY Daily News, "it's unlikely any zoning resolution could dictate that level of detail. The zoning code for eating and drinking establishments does not distinguish types of food. "
Testifying yesterday at the hearing, though, was our good friend, Dr. Lynn Silver of the NYC DOH. Silver is in charge of the city's efforts to reduce obesity rates in the city's poorest neighborhoods. The doctor told the committee that "restrictive zoning seemed to be a 'perfect example' of how government could help control the epidemic."
Not so fast. As one Yonkers teacher told the NY Post, "'Trying to hide a donut won't work...,' said Gary Londis...He said teaching kids to exercise and eat better would be more practical." Exactly so. In a city where 21% of kindergarteners are already obese drastic intervention is necessary.
Which brings us to Rivera's major new health initiative: the expansion of Dr. Oz's Health Corps concept. Health Corps, using a Peace Corps-like model, trains volunteers who then are placed in underserved high schools to teach various health-based lessons. The program is already being piloted in two city high schools and is designed to create a grass roots activism for health among the city's young people. Judging from its initial reception, the program could be the beginning of an attitude revolution, one that could lead to the kind of life-style changes that would make any zoning change superfluous.
Assisting in these lifestyle alternations should be the fast food companies that Councilman Rivera cites. It would make perfect sense for the McDonalds of the world to team up with Health Corps to encourage healthy eating and proper exercise. Childhood obesity and diabetes are socially and economically costly and the best way to combat these epidemics is, in partnership with food retailers, to convince young people to make improved choices.
Wednesday, June 21, 2006
New Direction for CBAs?
In today's Crain's Insider($) the newsletter is reporting that a local development corp has been formed to "negotiate a benefits agreement on behalf of neighbors of Columbia University's planned second campus in Manhattanville." The group, seeded with $350,000 provided by City Hall, consists of 13 reps from community, bushiness and residential factions.
As Crain's wonders, could this be a change of policy on the part of the Bloomberg Administration when it comes to the approval of CBAs? The mayor's criticism of the negotiations around the Mets stadium apparently devolved more from his lack of control over the process than from any philosophical disagreement with the CBA concept.
That being said there is some merit in the Columbia approach -as long as the LDC is actually representative of the impacted community. It gives some rationality, and hopefully some transparency, to the CBA process. It'll be interesting to see how this turns out and what the reactions will be from some of Columbia's opponents.
In any case it is a sharp departure from the manner in which these things are done in the Bronx. We finally got some reaction from BP Carrion over his jettisoning of some CB#4 members because of their opposition to the Beep's Yankee Stadium plans. As the NY Daily News reports this morning, Adolfo's view of the community resembles that of Louis the XIV ("Le etat c'est moi"): "My very clear expectation is that these appointees are there to carry out a vision for the borough president and the leadership of this borough, and that's simply what I expect." We'll see whether these turn out to be words to live by or to eat.
As Crain's wonders, could this be a change of policy on the part of the Bloomberg Administration when it comes to the approval of CBAs? The mayor's criticism of the negotiations around the Mets stadium apparently devolved more from his lack of control over the process than from any philosophical disagreement with the CBA concept.
That being said there is some merit in the Columbia approach -as long as the LDC is actually representative of the impacted community. It gives some rationality, and hopefully some transparency, to the CBA process. It'll be interesting to see how this turns out and what the reactions will be from some of Columbia's opponents.
In any case it is a sharp departure from the manner in which these things are done in the Bronx. We finally got some reaction from BP Carrion over his jettisoning of some CB#4 members because of their opposition to the Beep's Yankee Stadium plans. As the NY Daily News reports this morning, Adolfo's view of the community resembles that of Louis the XIV ("Le etat c'est moi"): "My very clear expectation is that these appointees are there to carry out a vision for the borough president and the leadership of this borough, and that's simply what I expect." We'll see whether these turn out to be words to live by or to eat.
Tuesday, June 20, 2006
Spitzer Withholds Support for Fair Share
As the NY Post is reporting today, and it's a sure sign that Eliot Spitzer feels his poll position is comfortable indeed, the Democratic candidate for governor has split with his party on the so-called Wal-Mart health care bill. Spitzer believes that "Fair Share" is not the kind of comprehensive health care reform that he feels New York State needs.
Knowing Spitzer and watching his demonstration of political independence over the past few years we'd be shocked if this split is viewed will be viewed as an anomaly when the dust settles on Eliot's career. If we were a status quo Democrats we'd be just a little bit worried with Mr. Spitzer as governor, Since we don't fit into that category you can describe us as quite sanguine about a Spitzer governorship.
Knowing Spitzer and watching his demonstration of political independence over the past few years we'd be shocked if this split is viewed will be viewed as an anomaly when the dust settles on Eliot's career. If we were a status quo Democrats we'd be just a little bit worried with Mr. Spitzer as governor, Since we don't fit into that category you can describe us as quite sanguine about a Spitzer governorship.
Jewbilation in Bentonville
For all those critics of Wal-Mart who railed against the company's homogenization of America with its vanilla box architecture there is news that should get us all to re-think our harsh critiques. What kind of news could cause such a sea change in attitude? Here it is: The Jews are coming to Bentonville.
As the NY Times reports this morning in a front page story, the growth of global Wal-Mart is threatening to turn Bentonville, Arkansas into a cosmopolitan metropolis. Hundreds of executives and employees of suppliers have been drawn to the Wal-Mart corporate home and there are now enough Jewish families to support a synagogue.
Talk about irony. All throughout the country the Wal-Mart behemoth is eliminating the diversity of small businesses and neighborhood retail. In fact, as we have ben commenting, this is just what will happen in Monsey, New York if the Walmonster gets the approval to build a supercenter in this heavily Orthodox Jewish community.
So while a cosmopolitan feel of cultural diversity begins to give Bentonville a different communal flavor, the drive toward eliminating these positive features of American communal life continues with Wal-Mart's drive towards lebensraum. Can this trend be stopped? Let us all pray.
As the NY Times reports this morning in a front page story, the growth of global Wal-Mart is threatening to turn Bentonville, Arkansas into a cosmopolitan metropolis. Hundreds of executives and employees of suppliers have been drawn to the Wal-Mart corporate home and there are now enough Jewish families to support a synagogue.
Talk about irony. All throughout the country the Wal-Mart behemoth is eliminating the diversity of small businesses and neighborhood retail. In fact, as we have ben commenting, this is just what will happen in Monsey, New York if the Walmonster gets the approval to build a supercenter in this heavily Orthodox Jewish community.
So while a cosmopolitan feel of cultural diversity begins to give Bentonville a different communal flavor, the drive toward eliminating these positive features of American communal life continues with Wal-Mart's drive towards lebensraum. Can this trend be stopped? Let us all pray.
Monday, June 19, 2006
Shuffle Board in the Bronx
In today's NY Times the paper gets around to the controversy surrounding the cashiering of many of the members of CB #4 in the Bronx by BP Carrion. One member, housing and land use chair Mary Blasingame, was one of the most concerned and conscientious community board members we've ever met. This is all about political payback. The BP was embarrassed by the board members he had appointed and he wasn't going to sit still for that.
Put simply the Yankees plan was no good for the High Bridge community and the board knew that. AC didn't give a rat's ass because he has his sights set on bigger things, something which a new ball park will help him achieve.
As the Times points out this was the second time that the BP had shafted this local community. "In February, several board members said a community benefits agreement negotiated by Mr. Carrion with the Related Companies for a new shopping mall at the site of the Bronx Terminal Market had shortchanged Bronx residents."
Whether this all comes back to haunt Carrion remains to be seen. One local resident is circulating a critical letter concerning Adolfo's failure to reappoint community-minded board members. AS Maria Simmons told the Times, "Don't play with people who put their trust in you."
Put simply the Yankees plan was no good for the High Bridge community and the board knew that. AC didn't give a rat's ass because he has his sights set on bigger things, something which a new ball park will help him achieve.
As the Times points out this was the second time that the BP had shafted this local community. "In February, several board members said a community benefits agreement negotiated by Mr. Carrion with the Related Companies for a new shopping mall at the site of the Bronx Terminal Market had shortchanged Bronx residents."
Whether this all comes back to haunt Carrion remains to be seen. One local resident is circulating a critical letter concerning Adolfo's failure to reappoint community-minded board members. AS Maria Simmons told the Times, "Don't play with people who put their trust in you."
Focus on Economic Impact for Monsey Wal-Mart
In yesterday's Journal News Sulaiman Beg continues his excellent work reporting on the evaluation process for the proposed Monsey Wal-Mart, in particular the Ramapo Town Board's decision to require a full review of the store's socio-economic impact. As Beg points out, "A decision to have the developer...study the economic ramifications of the project has proved to be a plus for the development's opponents."
Indeed it is a plus for opponents but, as the Alliance's Richard Lipsky points out, "This is a victory for the community...It's great that discretion was used to expand the scope and look at these essential issues. It's important information that needs to be examined." What needs to be done now is to insure that the kind of study that is done actually examines the real impact that a Wal-Mart can have on a local economy.
This is particularly true for the Monsey-Spring Valley area. As deputy town attorney Richard Ackerman says, "Why build new stores when there are already vacant ones?" The reaction of the developer also is cause for concern. Jerrold Bermingham says that Wal-Mart could "revitalize" this section of RT. 59 "making it more appealing to other national retailers."
If Bermingham believes that the building of a Wal-Mart will prompt a flood of additional national chains into the area than he better include these projections in the economic impact analysis. We know the kind of devastation that a supercenter can cause and an additional two or three chain stores will only exacerbate the situation. This is not good news for Monsey and Spring Valley retailers.
In fact the JN talks to our friend Abe Stauber who is busy organizing the Monsey retail community. Stauber doesn't see "how the project could be good for the heavily Orthodox Jewish Community." "Look what happened to downtown Spring Valley when the Nanuet Mall opened. I don't see a silver lining in the whole thing."
The next step is to prepare for the July town meeting. The purpose of the gathering will be to alert the impacted communities to the "high cost of low prices." The more people are educated the more difficult it will be for the developer to argue the putative merits of a Wal-Mart on the overcrowded traffic corridor of Rt. 59.
Indeed it is a plus for opponents but, as the Alliance's Richard Lipsky points out, "This is a victory for the community...It's great that discretion was used to expand the scope and look at these essential issues. It's important information that needs to be examined." What needs to be done now is to insure that the kind of study that is done actually examines the real impact that a Wal-Mart can have on a local economy.
This is particularly true for the Monsey-Spring Valley area. As deputy town attorney Richard Ackerman says, "Why build new stores when there are already vacant ones?" The reaction of the developer also is cause for concern. Jerrold Bermingham says that Wal-Mart could "revitalize" this section of RT. 59 "making it more appealing to other national retailers."
If Bermingham believes that the building of a Wal-Mart will prompt a flood of additional national chains into the area than he better include these projections in the economic impact analysis. We know the kind of devastation that a supercenter can cause and an additional two or three chain stores will only exacerbate the situation. This is not good news for Monsey and Spring Valley retailers.
In fact the JN talks to our friend Abe Stauber who is busy organizing the Monsey retail community. Stauber doesn't see "how the project could be good for the heavily Orthodox Jewish Community." "Look what happened to downtown Spring Valley when the Nanuet Mall opened. I don't see a silver lining in the whole thing."
The next step is to prepare for the July town meeting. The purpose of the gathering will be to alert the impacted communities to the "high cost of low prices." The more people are educated the more difficult it will be for the developer to argue the putative merits of a Wal-Mart on the overcrowded traffic corridor of Rt. 59.
Saturday, June 17, 2006
Bottle Bill Bottled Up
The yearly dance in Albany over the expansion of the "Bottle Bill" has just about ended with the legislation failing to be sent to the Senate floor for a vote. This is good news for all of the state's food stores that have been turned into garbage dumps ("transfer stations?") in this flawed and misguided environmental effort.
What gets us is the determination of the folks at NYPIRG and the Environmental Planning Lobby to put businesses on the front line of the solid waste issue when better alternatives exist (We're still waiting for NYPIRG to support any policy that would be good for business-Whose public interest is it anyway?).This is especially true for NYC stores that lack the space to adequately handle the deposit containers.
When it comes to these solid waste problems all of these groups are missing calculators. Their view seems to be: "We don't care what these initiatives will cost the stores or the tax payers." The problem is that the expense of the effort is not effective at really addressing the problem.
This callous disregard is particularly evident in the call to continue to expand deposits will simultaneously running an expensive and inefficient curbside collection program. Since we have examined the entire solid waste/deposit equation we've concluded that the only sensible way to expand the deposit system is to take it out of local stores and establish well-funded free standing redemption centers. Deposits can work more effectively in a system where everyone has the proper incentive to redeem and recycle.
What gets us is the determination of the folks at NYPIRG and the Environmental Planning Lobby to put businesses on the front line of the solid waste issue when better alternatives exist (We're still waiting for NYPIRG to support any policy that would be good for business-Whose public interest is it anyway?).This is especially true for NYC stores that lack the space to adequately handle the deposit containers.
When it comes to these solid waste problems all of these groups are missing calculators. Their view seems to be: "We don't care what these initiatives will cost the stores or the tax payers." The problem is that the expense of the effort is not effective at really addressing the problem.
This callous disregard is particularly evident in the call to continue to expand deposits will simultaneously running an expensive and inefficient curbside collection program. Since we have examined the entire solid waste/deposit equation we've concluded that the only sensible way to expand the deposit system is to take it out of local stores and establish well-funded free standing redemption centers. Deposits can work more effectively in a system where everyone has the proper incentive to redeem and recycle.
Friday, June 16, 2006
More CBA Controversy
A few days ago the NY Times weighed in on the controversy roiling the CBA discussion that we've been commenting on extensively. One of the most significant questions that the Times story raises is "whether the groups signing the document really speak for the community."
The other important issue is the role of the municipality. In some jurisdictions the city is a party to the agreement since many of the provisions impinge on quasi-public functions. In NYC, however, there is no clearly defined process and the developers are forced, if they want to utilize this mechanism to garner support for a project, to wing it.
This makes some in the development community nervous. As one attorney remarked, "There are no guidelines, no control. The transparency is not there. You just don't know what you're walking into."
What clearly doesn't make any sense is the suggestion of one Manhattan community board chairperson that these entities ought to be brought into the process, "They can look at the bigger picture," said Patricia Jones of Community Board #9. The community boards are representative of nothing but the elected officials who appoint them and, as the furor over Board 4 in the Bronx demonstrates, if they go off the political reservation they are quickly shown the door.
We do agree that the process needs to be made more rational so that the slick Potamkin Village style CBAs (like the one for Gateway) aren't deemed acceptable. The mayor and the council are apparently reviewing the entire issue and, as land use chair Melinda Katz says, "We can probably learn a lot from other jurisdictions..."
The other important issue is the role of the municipality. In some jurisdictions the city is a party to the agreement since many of the provisions impinge on quasi-public functions. In NYC, however, there is no clearly defined process and the developers are forced, if they want to utilize this mechanism to garner support for a project, to wing it.
This makes some in the development community nervous. As one attorney remarked, "There are no guidelines, no control. The transparency is not there. You just don't know what you're walking into."
What clearly doesn't make any sense is the suggestion of one Manhattan community board chairperson that these entities ought to be brought into the process, "They can look at the bigger picture," said Patricia Jones of Community Board #9. The community boards are representative of nothing but the elected officials who appoint them and, as the furor over Board 4 in the Bronx demonstrates, if they go off the political reservation they are quickly shown the door.
We do agree that the process needs to be made more rational so that the slick Potamkin Village style CBAs (like the one for Gateway) aren't deemed acceptable. The mayor and the council are apparently reviewing the entire issue and, as land use chair Melinda Katz says, "We can probably learn a lot from other jurisdictions..."
More Monsey Heat on Wal-Mart
We have already reported on the decision of the Ramapo Planning Board to expand the scope of the Wal-Mart EIS. We did,however, miss Sulaiman Beg's story in the Journal News that previewed the action last Sunday. The story did report that the Board had insisted that the developer would have to "complete a more comprehensive traffic study" but didn't yet have the information that it would also insist on the economic impact analysis that the Alliance had requested.
The paper did underscore the Alliance's concerns and the Board's reaction two days later indicates that it is possible to get the planners to recognize some important variables if the proper effort is made. We will continue to do this since awareness of the development and its potential impact is not clearly understood by the nearby communities.
That is why we have been working with the nascent Ramapo Jewish Chamber of Commerce and its founder Abe Stauber. Yesterday we met with a group of Abe's retailers in Monsey and, unlike Frank Garcia's make believe ballroom, these are real store owners with real concerns about the potential impact of Wal-Mart on their businesses. When all is said and done we think that this is one Chamber that will have a big impact on the outcome in Monsey.
The paper did underscore the Alliance's concerns and the Board's reaction two days later indicates that it is possible to get the planners to recognize some important variables if the proper effort is made. We will continue to do this since awareness of the development and its potential impact is not clearly understood by the nearby communities.
That is why we have been working with the nascent Ramapo Jewish Chamber of Commerce and its founder Abe Stauber. Yesterday we met with a group of Abe's retailers in Monsey and, unlike Frank Garcia's make believe ballroom, these are real store owners with real concerns about the potential impact of Wal-Mart on their businesses. When all is said and done we think that this is one Chamber that will have a big impact on the outcome in Monsey.
The Bronx Wal-Mart
As the organizing work of the Alliance and its allies continues in the Bronx the rumors keep persisting that the giant retailer has its sights set on the city's poorest borough. In today's NY Daily News the paper is reporting on the grass roots effort and the gyrations of some of the Walmonster's putative supporters who are attempting to distance themselves from the retailer's radioactivity.
Of course the Wal-Mart flack believes that the opposition is "a small minority of special interests" who "stand in the way of choice." We guess that he doesn't read his own public opinion surveys that show that the store is generating the king of similar negative ratings that our current president is trying desperately to raise.
What's most interesting in the story is the reporting on the booty capitalist effort to sow support with cash. For instance, even though it doesn't have a store in the Bronx the retailer joined the Bronx Chamber of Commerce. The Chamber, no doubt embarrassed by this hand-out, is scheduled to vote today to terminate the Wal-Mart membership. As the Alliance's Matt Lipsky says, "We fear Wal-Mart is giving-and will keep giving-money to create support for itself."
Which brings us to old friend Frank Garcia and his Bronx Hispanic Chamber of Commerce. We have already commented on our suspicions that Frank is looking for ways to promote the company. With all of the heat being laid on him, however, Frankie from the Bronx is shucking and ducking-"people are spreading rumors about me," Garcia said. We can just see Garcia burning those travel vouchers to Bentonville.
Of course the Wal-Mart flack believes that the opposition is "a small minority of special interests" who "stand in the way of choice." We guess that he doesn't read his own public opinion surveys that show that the store is generating the king of similar negative ratings that our current president is trying desperately to raise.
What's most interesting in the story is the reporting on the booty capitalist effort to sow support with cash. For instance, even though it doesn't have a store in the Bronx the retailer joined the Bronx Chamber of Commerce. The Chamber, no doubt embarrassed by this hand-out, is scheduled to vote today to terminate the Wal-Mart membership. As the Alliance's Matt Lipsky says, "We fear Wal-Mart is giving-and will keep giving-money to create support for itself."
Which brings us to old friend Frank Garcia and his Bronx Hispanic Chamber of Commerce. We have already commented on our suspicions that Frank is looking for ways to promote the company. With all of the heat being laid on him, however, Frankie from the Bronx is shucking and ducking-"people are spreading rumors about me," Garcia said. We can just see Garcia burning those travel vouchers to Bentonville.
Thursday, June 15, 2006
Dances With Schnorers
In today's Newsday the paper is reporting on the counterattack being launched by a pair of Long Island Indian tribes against the Alliance's effort (as well as a lawsuit filed by Gristedes), to get the state to enforce its own tax laws. The tribes are arguing that the tax "removes the incentive" for people to shop at their stores.
This incentive, as the Alliance's Richard Lipsky told Newsday, is in fact the greater proportion of the cost of a pack of cigarettes, and the sale of these smokes in NYC has contributed to the loss of over $250 million a year in business for city stores. If the tribes need the money than they should find ways to do business that don't unfairly rig the playing field against struggling small store owners.
This incentive, as the Alliance's Richard Lipsky told Newsday, is in fact the greater proportion of the cost of a pack of cigarettes, and the sale of these smokes in NYC has contributed to the loss of over $250 million a year in business for city stores. If the tribes need the money than they should find ways to do business that don't unfairly rig the playing field against struggling small store owners.
Wednesday, June 14, 2006
Wal-Mart Scoped In Monsey
It's always refreshing when people who are charged with taking care of the public interest actually take their responsibility seriously. Such is the case with Mr. Sylvain Klein, chair of the Ramapo Town Board.
As we commented yesterday the draft scoping document for the proposed left a lot to be desired when it came to socio-economic as well as traffic impacts. We had a long chat with the chairman and he promised that he would try to include this missing data analysis in the scope. Later that evening he lived up to his promise and the scope was amended to include the business impact in Monsey and Spring Valley. In addition, Saturday was added as a peak traffic day at our suggestion.
All of which doesn't mean that the RTB will do the right thing in this matter. Much work needs to be done before we can say that the powers-that-be are paying attention. This was the concern expressed by someone commenting on last nights meeting (see yesterday's post). The poster feels that "St Lawrence...has already made his deal and is screwing the rest of us..."
We understand all the cynicism but we're not willing to throw in the towel by any means. We've been in fights where the key elected official actually brought the developer to the area yet was forced, when the community sentiment was passionately expressed, to side with his constituents. That is the gaunlet that we face here.
We are, however, not without allies. So far Legislator Fried and Spring Valley village attorney Bruce Levine (running for the legislature) are solidly in our camp and we're reaching out to all of the others as well. Our town meeting will be held in July and we expect that, once the public gets a better idea of what this project means, the opposition will become a crescendo.
As we commented yesterday the draft scoping document for the proposed left a lot to be desired when it came to socio-economic as well as traffic impacts. We had a long chat with the chairman and he promised that he would try to include this missing data analysis in the scope. Later that evening he lived up to his promise and the scope was amended to include the business impact in Monsey and Spring Valley. In addition, Saturday was added as a peak traffic day at our suggestion.
All of which doesn't mean that the RTB will do the right thing in this matter. Much work needs to be done before we can say that the powers-that-be are paying attention. This was the concern expressed by someone commenting on last nights meeting (see yesterday's post). The poster feels that "St Lawrence...has already made his deal and is screwing the rest of us..."
We understand all the cynicism but we're not willing to throw in the towel by any means. We've been in fights where the key elected official actually brought the developer to the area yet was forced, when the community sentiment was passionately expressed, to side with his constituents. That is the gaunlet that we face here.
We are, however, not without allies. So far Legislator Fried and Spring Valley village attorney Bruce Levine (running for the legislature) are solidly in our camp and we're reaching out to all of the others as well. Our town meeting will be held in July and we expect that, once the public gets a better idea of what this project means, the opposition will become a crescendo.
Smoking on the Rise
The NY Daily News is reporting today that there is an increase in the percentage of New Yorkers who are smoking after a two year period of decline. Health Commissioner Frieden is using this increase to once again call on the state legislature to pass the city's proposed 50 cents a pack increase.
This is not a great idea since the level of illegal street sales has continued unabated and the Indian retail loophole is still in place. Interestingly, Congressman Charlie Rangel has weighed in against any new cigarette tax since he feels that it "unfairly targets the poor." Let's close the loophole, eliminate as much as possible the high level of street sales, and then a more rational debate about taxing cigarettes might make more sense.
This is not a great idea since the level of illegal street sales has continued unabated and the Indian retail loophole is still in place. Interestingly, Congressman Charlie Rangel has weighed in against any new cigarette tax since he feels that it "unfairly targets the poor." Let's close the loophole, eliminate as much as possible the high level of street sales, and then a more rational debate about taxing cigarettes might make more sense.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)